Class action filed against SpaceX over mass layoffs
washingtonexaminer.com
washingtonexaminer.com
Employment law not withstanding, I didn't know they'd had a layoff. Anyone else have any info?
In short, they claim they were just laying off their "bottom" 5% a week after doing reviews, and are in the process of hiring an additional 20% new employees.
Whether this constitutes a layoff is at the moment unclear; it's been noted that at least one other company (in)famous for this practice treated these actions as layoffs, and of course if they were "fired for cause" as SpaceX seems to be claiming they aren't due unemployment, which of course would increase what SpaceX has to pay for that.
The nastier claim is that SpaceX didn't pay all the back wages/salaries they were due, which is rather white line and something the government cares rather a lot about, if for no other reason than it deprives them of taxes.
These "devils" then refused to pay our salaries for the pay period up to that date, and I learned, working with the (former) company lawyer, that doing this was not just a misdemeanor, but there was a state agency staffed with humorless people (they've heard everything) tasked with extracting back pay from employers.
In most other domains there's no criminal law involved nor any special units of government tasked with this. Note also that Virginia is considered by many not to be "worker friendly".
Your example is an interesting one. Perhaps because stiffing builders and people who repair stuff is so easy, and most certainly because this involves real estate or other tangible personal property (e.g. a car), there's legal, but still civil law mechanisms in most/all states to make them whole, they can get what's generally called a Mechanic's Lien: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mechanic's_lien
It's hard to say without reading the actual filing, which I'm not going to bother with, but I think they don't mean actual back pay, but rather the notification-plus-60-days-worth of pay that should be due (if it is a layoff). Based on:
"“Because defendants failed to pay plaintiffs and other similarly situated employees their wages…defendants failed to pay those employees timely after each employee’s separation of employment,” the complaint states."
I would think that makes it part of the general "it's actually a layoff but you didn't treat it like one" theory of the suit, which is arguable, rather than not actually paying accrued wages, which is not.
I note your use of speech marks around the word bottom. I'm just wondering how you put structural technicians on a scale.
In other words, does the effectiveness of an individual in this kind of multiply connected technical environment not basically depend on a lot of other people?
It isn't selling vacuum cleaners really is it?
I of course used them precisely for the sorts reasons you cite: outside of domains like sales, where there are concrete metrics, this sort of thing is necessarily a political exercise, one that has harmed many companies including Microsoft.
However, if you read the referenced bigger discussion, you'll get some hints that maybe SpaceX can get away with this, essentially their employees believe they're on a mission, which is something I can understand.
Although I still wonder about the viability of a super-high tech, literally rocket science, company with an average tenure of 1.5 years. Perhaps they'll end up losing one or more zillion dollar payloads due to this and then try to change their ways, but that can be extremely difficult once a company is driven at the micro level by internal politics instead of external success.
I have some knowledge of medium scale construction projects (50 tenancy flats aka apartments) and the builders are contracted, assemble stuff in the right order, then complete their contracts. If there is one operative that is obviously not performing/dangerous, they get invited to leave. None of this 'worst 5%' malarkey.
This is outright illegal, and California labor law is very clear on this. If true, not only will back wages need to be paid, there are steep penalties. Its up there with not paying your tax withholdings to the state/federal governments (i.e. personal liability).
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8078194
also discussion on reddit 14 days ago
And your first link about got 35 comments and some high quality discussion, that's not bad at all.