An open letter to Adam Shostack, the man who raped my wife
adamshostack.com
adamshostack.com
People I love have been raped, and their rapists don't deserve any sympathy. It's a truly devastating crime.
I still feel guilty at not having been at Def Con that night
to protect my wife from you. I still feel angry at her (and
ashamed at myself for being so) for her poor choices that
led to her being in a situation where she ended up blackout
drunk and alone with you (someone she viewed as a safe
friend of ours)
Even if a woman makes the dumbest, worst, most ill-advised choices in the world (and I'm not saying this woman did) she does not deserve to be raped.(Edit: the previous sentence is aimed at anybody who shifts some or all of the blame to victims of rape. I don't believe that this woman's husband was doing that!)
Sometimes you can't stop a rape (or any other attack) but sometimes you can, and if you can and don't, it's worse in a way.
a) They're not a convicted rapist, and
b) The reason they're not a convicted rapist is because you, personally, decided you couldn't be bothered pressing charges
Take it to court or stfu, dude.
It's quite possible, due to lacking or conflicting evidence, for the question of someone's guilt to be basically "uncertain", in which case they probably can't be convicted, but they also probably can't win a defamation suit. See, e.g. O.J. Simpson, where being acquitted of murder didn't stop anyone from continuing to accuse him publicly of it.
Your attitude is part of the reason people are raped: their rapists know they can likely get away with it because their victims face this kind of abuse and doubt. You are literally part of the problem.
> I wonder what US defamation law has to say about
> publicly accusing someone of being a rapist
It varies from state to state, but one thing is pretty constant: it's only libel/defamation/etc if the claim is false.If you're going to sue somebody for defamation you need to be able to prove the statements are false.
It's bad that this is how the world is, but telling someone "Your attitude is part of the reason people are raped" is just as bad.
You are basically saying anyone can be accused of rape and automatically be considered guilty. That is arguably worse that the alternative of being unable to prove rape.
> but one thing is pretty constant: it's only libel/defamation/etc if the claim is false.
That is not true. If you can prove it was true that it's not defamation, but the reverse is not the case.
> If you're going to sue somebody for defamation you need to be able to prove the statements are false.
That is not true either. You just have to prove they made the statement and that it was defamatory.
Make sure there's some injuries, so that the lack of consent is obvious when you go to the police, which you of course should do immediately afterwards with a black eye or a broken arm or whatever. It's much better to get a broken arm than to let your rapist get away with it.
My estimate of this case based on the complete lack of evidence either way is... I dunno, fifty percent that she was actually raped, fifty percent that she consented and later lied about it. Maybe leaning towards the latter scenario.
EDIT: Nevada statute § 200.366 ¶ 1, emphasis added, "A person who subjects another person to sexual penetration, or who forces another person to make a sexual penetration on himself or herself or another, or on a beast, against the will of the victim or under conditions in which the perpetrator knows or should know that the victim is mentally or physically incapable of resisting or understanding the nature of his or her conduct, is guilty of sexual assault."
If you've done this, you're a rapist.
Which is why my advice to anyone about to be raped is this: fucking fight back.
You shouldn't give people advice. Some people should, but not you.How do we know when something like this is true? If the accusation alone is enough to convict in the court of public opinion, then that places a powerful weapon into the hands of bad actors that might want to defame or depose rivals.
If the crime really occurred, it is a tragedy. However, by waiting so long, and weighing other concerns more highly than justice at the proper time, the author has basically given up his chance to pursue justice.
Now, 15 years later, it is a very poor time to suddenly think about justice again. Any pertinent evidence is lost. Witnesses for and against the prosecution would be hazy, and most like lost altogether.
Physical evidence should have been gathered right at the time of the crime. It is difficult work for the victim, but if we don't demand that standard for evidence collection, it opens up the criminal system to terrible abuse.
Taking such open letters at face value, 15 years after the fact, also would create an atmosphere that is intolerable for a free society. Accusations alone should not be enough to break a defendant. Even serious accusations. To treat this letter as anything other than fiction at this point would be bad on a systems level. Destroying people's careers just based on rumor and accusations was what Senator McCarthy used to do. We all decided that was a bad idea decades ago.
In undergrounds like hacking or cryptography, there is a lot of borderline people, so judging such a thing is uneasy. (i could tell lot of story of rape accusation some true some false)
All i can say it's that when someone is a true asshole, he will not stop to be one and one day or another he will fall for that.
kind of kharma.
Sean: Don't let this event consume you and define you. Because then he wins - he caused you harm, and you let it fester.
Instead face those memories and move past them, rejoin your social circle, make those startups you wanted, and be a CTO.
That's how you win: By not letting it hurt you.
You didn't write much about your wife except for: "and for her initial instinct to do anything and everything at all afterwards to avoid having to admit she was a rape victim". I know nothing about her, but perhaps this was her way of not letting this event define her?
By not admitting to be a victim, perhaps this way she won't feel like a victim. After all even by admitting to be a victim, you can not change what happened, but you can change how you react. Perhaps. I don't know her obviously, maybe this is bad advice. But consider it, because what you've been doing for the last 15 years doesn't seem to be working.
That's some rational thinking right there.
Many, many rape survivors agree that rape trials are often far worse than the actual rape. Even a conviction won't undo what is done, and in a rape trial the defense feverishly tries to prove that the victim is a slut/unfaithful/etc who wanted the sex - and this often involves digging up all kinds of painful and personal information on the victim.
Please save your anger for rapists, not their victims.