Seems like this presages this idea of Kolmogorov[0] Complexity by half a century.
In some ways, this is a good example to avoid making the "fallacy fallacy" - just because someone's argument/reasoning is wrong or incoherent, it doesn't mean the point itself is wrong.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fallacy_fallacy
The solution of other similar things like the halting problem, is also a testament to the power of mathematics and formal language, and gives us some hope that this problem (and similar things like consciousness) will be solved in the future.
It is hard to believe that this nonsense is still being promoted all this time later.