How do you scientifically prove this?
First, you must isolate a human being in such a way you can account for every single calorie incoming and outgoing. Incoming calories are relatively easy to measure, but for outgoing you have to at least measure:
- How much heat is produced by the body (how much energy is expended keeping the room at the same temperature) - How many calories did the body use to warm sweat and pee: collect every single drop of sweat and pee, measure its volume and temperature as soon as it leaves the body, compare to temperature of water ingested. - Collect every single particle of stool leaving the body, measure temperature, weight and calorie content.
Only after you have a human being isolated in a way all calories in = calories out, then you can test the "Stop eating and you'll lose weight" hypothesis. Before then, anybody with such a claim is just blurting out junk science.