Samsung Unveils the Galaxy Note 4
techcrunch.com
techcrunch.com
"The sloping screen’s default status is as a quick launcher of sorts, with easy access to a bunch of your most-used apps. There are a number of widgets, though, tickers of sorts that let you flip through news or tweets or information about how many steps you’ve taken. And you can do it all without ever changing or disturbing what you see on the larger display. In some apps, the edge acts as a toolbar, offering easy access to font menus or camera modes or in-app settings. At night, it can be your alarm clock, the time displayed on the side of the phone so you can see it without taking your head off your pillow. It’s an odd idea, turning this vertical rail into essentially an always-on secondary display"
How the hell does Samsung find it sustainable, let alone profitable, to support all these variations and iterations?
Am I missing something here?
It's no different than a VC funding a portfolio of startups. Note that their wildly successful phablet form factor was only one of many in-market variations. Keep what the crowd/sales identifies as good, discard the rest. If executive leadership supports research, manufacturing and distribution in lego/modular fashion, this approach can become embedded in the culture. It's a statistical approach to creativity.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/haydnshaughnessy/2013/03/07/why-...
Korean (?) version is Cortex-A53, but international version is 32-bit.
I gotta say I found the Note quite nice, I was surprised how good the stylus worked. I'm not a fan of Android skins (the 1+ wins by a large margin with official CyanogenMod support here) though, even if some of the additions looked nice and sensible.
At the moment I'd say both are a little too big for me, but I understand that this isn't a factor for lots of guys and - well - the phablet features (split screen, stylus) wouldn't make a lot of sense with a tiny display.
Here's my micro review of the 3 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8264661
Short answer, the 4 looks like a fairly minor upgrade to the 3. If you're price sensitive that probably means you can get a 3 at a steep discount pretty soon (I got mine for $99 on contract) and won't be too disappointing. Spec wise, the 3 is already ahead of just about anything else on the market. I have a feeling it'll be a head of the iPhone 6 when that comes out.
I have a flip cover for it that makes it look like a high-end paper notebook from a distance and it's a bit narrower and much thinner than my moleskine notebooks, which is what it's largely replaced. The pen works fantastic even if the included software is a little funky in some places. It's very low latency compared to finger input and can even recognize the difference between the pen and your finger so you can grab the screen without writing on it. I can write on it about as fine as I can write in my moleskines. The case replaces the back panel so it doesn't add any thickness to the device except for the front panel, which has a nifty window that just shows the time and lets you answer calls without opening it up all the way. It folds around the back so you can use the phone without it getting in the way.
I showed it to my parents, and my octogenarian Dad, who's been struggling typing on his iphone (and hates hates hates it and has to use a stylus and reading glasses to use it at all), has already gone out and bought one and my mother is planning on upgrading from her flip phone to a Note very soon. Using it as a notepad is really natural for them, and after I showed them how to just email a pdf of their notes they were sold.
Battery life is absurd. It's kind of strange what a transformative experience great battery life has on a phone. It turns your phone from an adversary into a companion. After heavy usage all day (multiple hours of phone calls and otherwise almost constantly doing something with it all day) it's usually above 50% at the end of the day and still has 30-40% by the time I go to bed.
Amazingly, it fits pretty comfortably in my pocket. I don't wear skinny jeans so that kind of thing is usually not a problem for me. But I do find myself walking around with my phone more often than I realized. Usually on a call or something.
The battery is replaceable/upgradeable and there's an SD card slot so I can plop in another 64GB if I really need to. The camera is pretty good. I'm not in a habit of taking pictures with my phones, but the few I've taken were as good as my old point and shoot. I don't like the camera software however, there's some UI issues with it I think could be done much better.
And oh yeah, it has 3GB of RAM. It's hard to explain what that means for multitasking, but I used to regularly have apps shutdown in the background when I was doing something else. Now I can play music, answer and email, browse for the answer I'm about to type and have navigation running in the background without worrying something is going to get killed.
My phone is almost as powerful as the desktop computer I recently replaced. Except it's no in my pocket.
Issues: The Samsung TouchWiz I could live without, as I could with all the crapware installed by Verizon (there's a couple useful things installed so it's not a total loss). Some of the defaults are just plain stupid, like pushing home on the home screen to auto launch some kind of magazine app I don't want to use. It took a little while to figure out how to kill that "feature". I also wish the flip case had a lock position to use as a kickstand. This is something that Apple wouldn't have gotten wrong. It took me a couple hours to reconfigure the default factory phone into something I can really use, but it wasn't particularly painful. Performance is off the charts, GTA 3 plays like a dream on it for example as does Caustic (a CPU heavy soft synth).
The capacitive buttons also don't light-up by default so you have to know they're there to push them. Then they light up. It's kind of stupid. They do provide a menu key on the Note 3, which I love. I don't get the obsession with moving menus from the dedicated menu button up to some random location in every application's gui. Fortunately, most apps observe the guidelines and remove the menu button in the gui and use the phone's button instead. (yeah yeah, well designed apps shouldn't have menus blah blah, well apps do have menus and they aren't going anywhere and shuffling the icon around the screen is worse then putting it under a dedicated button IMHO).
I need more USB 3 cables. Every cable I have anywhere else is one of the old style USB 2 cables, which works fine with the phone. But being able to recharge it ultra quick with the 3 cable is really nice.
Unless Samsung really craps the phones up in the future, I'm pretty sure my next phone in a couple years will probably be another Note.
I rather suspect that Samsung is deliberately hobbling my Note II with Touchwiz iterations. The phone is drastically slower than it was when I bought it, despite reformats and careful management of open apps. The camera is no longer accessible from the lock screen and takes eons to open after unlocking. Once the camera app is loaded, I have to manually turn on HDR EVERY SINGLE TIME. And the pictures it takes are pretty terrible -- there seems to be terrible shutter lag, nearly all photos are now grainy and blurry, and many of the pictures I take are never saved to memory.
It's inexplicable. I love the phone's display and battery life, and it's still PERFECT for reading books and articles. But the camera and Touchwiz have just gotten crappier and crappier.
I'd love to upgrade to CyanogenMod, but unfortunately this is the international version of the Note II with a proprietary Exynos processor -- Samsung never released sufficient information for CyanogenMod to work properly. So I'm stuck with Touchwiz and a deliberately crippled phone.
For this reason alone, I think I'm switching back to Apple this fall. The iPhone camera is still best-in-class, and the camera app is SO fast to open and use. I just feel stupid paying a price premium for Apple when all Samsung needed to do was not cripple my camera.
Haha whoops. I started this post with the intention of praising the Note. My Note II WAS a perfect phablet for its era, but Samsung has deliberately or negligently crippled my once-beloved phone. Once the phablet iPhone is released and I find an iOS reader that compares to Android's Moon+ Reader, I have strong incentive to switch back to Apple.
Ironically, I'm also unhappy with my Note 2, but for a very different reason: It turns out the Nexus 7 LTE is just barely portable enough for me to carry around almost all the time, so it has become my goto device for ebooks, video and browsing. So I'm perfectly happy with my Note 2's software, but it has lost its size advantage and I want smaller hardware (maybe the Xperia Z3 Compact?).
I don't use my phone camera almost at all, just a personal thing. But the few times I've used the phone app on the Note 3 I definitely didn't really like it. The default Google one on the Nexus was definitely better. However, the image quality is awesome. I'll probably just get a better camera app and use that instead.
The s-pen has such a potential to be a killer feature, being able to store it in the phone body itself is enough of a feature to make it useful. Paint apps are amazing and now I'm no longer finger painting like I'm in kindergarten. If Samsung could just get their software game together they'd be unstoppable.
I'm very interested in what Apple is going to bring to the phablet market. If history is any guide, it'll definitely force vendors like Samsung to up their game. This is a very good thing IMHO. The phablet market has been Android only for too long and Apple does a much better job picking and setting trends.
Agreed about the S-Pen. I almost never use it, but my artist girlfriend LOVES to doodle with it and it makes a ton of sense for walk-and-talk jobs.
Samsung should be applauded for their innovation. When the first Galaxy Note premiered, every critic insisted that a tiny form factor and fingers-only were the only correct way to build a phone. To this day, articles on phablets are filled with hysterics about how large phones are terrible. I just hope that size innovation won't stop at 5.5-5.7 inches...
It's one of the few times in recent years I felt like technology had actually done something magical for me. In the long long list of things modern smartphones can replace, a notepad is now absolutely one of them.
It's taking me an effort to fit the s-pen into my workflow, but when I do, it's usually a good experience. It seems to me to be more a matter of realizing I have a digital notepad on hand and actually using it than anything wrong with the tech.
That's an interesting contrast to my Note 3 experience, in combination with the Gear Fit. Fantastic hardware, abysmal software that's so bad I went back to an iPhone 4S until the iPhone 6 comes out.
A few examples so you know I'm not just talking from my nether regions. S Note: great until it loses data. I think they've fixed it since, but not something I'm inspired to use for serious note taking. I mean, c'mon, your premier differentiating feature (take notes with a stylus) loses my data? Image Gallery: it has never worked. Take some pictures, there's no way to view them without a 3rd party app because Image Gallery pretends they don't exist. It did this straight out of the box. Reset the phone once (for reason other than Image Gallery), and it still didn't work. Those are just two examples, I'll not bore anyone with the rest.
I bought the Gear Fit. Again, nice hardware and a steaming pile of shit for firmware/software. Advertised features just plain didn't work (confirmed by others). At this point it looks like those advertised features are never going to work because Samsung has moved on to the next big idea.
Until Samsung can somehow convince me that the software running on their hardware is something more than just an afterthought written by summer high school interns (with apologies to high school interns that don't suck), it's the last piece of Samsung kit I will ever buy.
Samsung strikes me as a company that comes out with some great hardware ideas, and then doesn't know what to do with them. Alternatively, they might think cool hardware is enough, and software isn't an important part of the user experience. But I don't care what the root reason is, there's no more Samsung at our house.
But I have to admit, even then the S Note software is weird and funky. Too many mystery icons I can't remember what they do, and basic features like "delete this page" are buried in menus. It's definitely sub-optimal software. If somebody else came out with a good S-Pen enabled notepad app, I'd switch tommorrow.
Samsung software is definitely poor.
I'm not in the market for a Gear, but everything I've heard about it is that it's a dud. I'm definitely in the wait and see w/r to the wearables market.
Best I can tell, Samsung's fix was to auto-save on a timed interval. I haven't timed the intervals, but there is still a (smaller) risk of data loss if my guess is correct. But at least you shouldn't come back to review a note and find a blank page.
> If somebody else came out with a good S-Pen enabled notepad app, I'd switch tomorrow.
Papyrus looks pretty good. It could use some more work, but if your note-taking needs aren't complicated (IOW, it's no OneNote), it seems to be well done. I tried a bunch, and that seemed to be the best of the bunch. Others had more features but confusing UI, or just weren't as polished. The one thing that S Note has going for it is Evernote integration. If S Note hasn't lost your note, the Evernote integration works well and to my recollection never failed.
I'm going to give Papyrus a go, it looks focused and basic enough on that kind of workflow to keep me happy.
Me, much as I might dislike the Note 3 overall, it's the one thing that will have me keeping the Note around for a little while longer. But my SIM will remain in the iPhone. :-)
I gave Papyrus a go. It's exactly what I wanted and I've converted to it. Thanks for the recommendation. It's really well thought out and super focused. It even uses the phone's ability to recognize pen from finger touches by turning your finger into an eraser. It's kind of brilliant actually.
For some reason I never could quite get into OneNote and other note taking software. I think I have just enough of a weird way of taking notes that they don't seem to work for me.
I actually don't care too much about converting to text either, I'm happy just transcribing the cryptic notes and arrows and diagrams and such into longer form communications to my team, or into trackable actions or something as needed.
I'd say it's comparable to a Watcom device in terms of latency. It's not paper, but it's near enough that you can get used to it much more quickly than trying to deal with the longer latency of the finger input.
And yes, there's no friction feedback, so it feels like you're writing on slippery oil. It's off putting at first, but you also get used to it.
Is a moleskine and decent pen a better writing experience? Yeah sure. Have I stopped carrying one around with me in addition to my phone? Absolutely.