Denmark has had a few occasions in the last few years where this has failed because one bank failed to deliver their transactions one night.
Denmark has had a few occasions in the last few years where this has failed because one bank failed to deliver their transactions one night.
While it's probably critical for the future of humanity for a project like this to succeed, frankly anything that leaves the trust and reputation aspects to manual negotiation as per conventional business is just lipstick on a pig. In this sense, Bitcoin is superior. For some more ambitious ideas forming in this area check out http://ifex-project.org/
[1] Quote from European Data Protection Supervisor in response to FOIA: "since at least 2001" http://www.asktheeu.org/en/request/information_on_financial_...
[2] http://www.swift.com/about_swift/shownews?param_dcr=news.dat...
The ability of the US to seize USD transaction has nothing to do with any control they might have over SWIFT. All USD transfers -- even USD transfers between two EU citizens -- hapen via a US bank, because only US banks can have a USD balance.
The actual transfers happen by way of so-called US "intermediate" banks, who perform the actual USD transfer. The process is described here: https://bitcoinfoundation.org/2012/12/international-bank-tra...
There are USD balances right across the world. Some of them are backed with cash (really!). That's fundamentally because, unlike bitcoin or company shares, currency is what's known as a 'non-consolidated' asset: ie. there is no central ledger anywhere in the world with a complete list of who owns every piece of currency on issue, like exists for Bitcoin on the blockchain.
For electronic currency, there is a central ledger (for USD it's the Federal Reserve).
Thanks for a well written description and background of SWIFT, I think it is accurate.
I have a question on this paragraph:
>While it's probably critical for the future of humanity for a project like this to succeed, frankly anything that leaves the trust and reputation aspects to manual negotiation as per conventional business is just lipstick on a pig. In this sense, Bitcoin is superior. For some more ambitious ideas forming in this area check out http://ifex-project.org/
Does "for a project like this" refer to SWIFT or BankAPI? If SWIFT, then I understand. But if BankAPI, then you have misunderstood, because it does not "leaves the trust and reputation aspects to manual negotiation", since it's decentralized and peer-to-peer (or in this context bank-to-bank), just like a lot of other successful peer-to-peer technologies of which you mentioned one.
I think banking is an artificial industry, one that doesn't really have to exist. I believe that money that is state issued, electronically issued, trust that can be quantified, reputation and physical goods are all equally valid assets for forward-looking exchange protocols. I believe that any distinction between participants is farcical and that risk management models, encryption preferences, topology specification and other qualitative decisions regarding deployment must be left out of scope.
To clarify my original comment further, I do think that BankAPI, just at a glance, is probably focusing too much on the conventional world of banking rather than looking at the big picture ... which has nothing to do with banks and everything to do with a potential revolution in the way we organize society, removing anachronistic middle men and vested interests who consistently fail to demonstrate any meaningful reason for being while extracting vast quantities of wealth from society at large and encouraging the continuation of a socio-political and economic trajectory that will see our environment destroyed within a generation.
Part 1: http://engineering.zenpayroll.com/how-ach-works-a-developer-... (HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7636066)
Part 2: http://engineering.zenpayroll.com/how-ach-works-a-developer-... (HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7740967)
Part 3: http://engineering.zenpayroll.com/how-ach-works-a-developer-... (HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8007838)
The total balance of electronic currency in a commercial bank is tracked by the central bank of the currency in question (eg. the Federal Reserve for USD for the US, Danmarks Nationalbank for DKK in Denmark).
The Federal Reserve is the authority on the (electronic) USD balance of each US bank, and no non-US banks can have a USD balance (this happens via so-called intermediate banks where, for example, a Danish bank has a USD balance with a US "intermediate" bank).
Intrabank transfers (transfers from one account at a bank to another account in the same bank) is simply a change in that bank's local database. Interbank transfers (a transfer from one commercial bank to another) within the same country is handled by the central bank (since the central bank is the authority on the commercial bank balance of the currency they produce/manage).