Thanks To Gene Therapy, Monkeys See In Full Color
npr.org
npr.org
The three of us (out of ~20 people) who were color blind had rather different answers. One guy fell in the middle, he wasn't quite sure one way or the other. The other guy is leaning towards the treatment, primarily because art plays a large roll in his life.
I feel that I would not take the treatment. From what I can tell, being color blind seems to be more of an advantage than a disadvantage for me. While color is nice, it doesn't seem particularly useful in my life. On the other hand, the tendency to notice textures and patterns over the color they are in has frequently been useful to me. I notice movement faster (due to the texture changing, but not the colors), and I notice small differences easier.
I would really like to see how other people weigh in on the issue.
Does anyone know if short-sightedness/long-sightedness results in a corresponding benefit to the opposite-sightedness?
To be honest, it isn't an optimization. Its a trade off, that has benefits. An example would be being able to see infra-red light. You would be able to see more colors, which comes with all sorts of advantages (distance the color carries, how well it reflects, what it reflects off of, etc), but the trade off would be you would be even worse off when looking at a pattern. For whatever reason, the human brain (at least, this may be true for other species) considers color to encode quite a bit of information, and it is quite high up on the list of things to process.
Think of things which are obviously genetic and also obviously not beneficial, such as near-sightedness or teeth mis-alignment.
I don't drive, so the distance vision doesn't make much of a difference, but for someone who works in front of an LCD for 12+ hours a day, being able to fully utilize my LCD is a major bonus - I wouldn't trade that for being able to see stuff 20' out.
I have to assume that Y chromosomes have one colour-sensing cone otherwise by this logic all men would be dichromatic?
I'm also struggling to understand how if one X chromosome has these two genes, having two X chromosomes (so more of the same 2 genes) would result in different colour-sensing cones.
Finally, it's interesting that the identified tetrochomats cannot see things in the ultraviolet (or otherwise infrared) spectrum, only increased colour differentiation. Perhaps, they really are but the brain interprets them as related to our existing colour map, in the same way that regular trichromats identify a connection between red and violet.
(Doesn't seem likely -- I'd have thought that if he were doing that, he'd have learned much faster.)
So cute!
Empiricism 1, Rationalism 0
> Neitz and his team tried the experiment anyway.
Doing the experiment is empiricism; relying on a conceptual theory is rationalism. Theory is effective for predicting the logical consequences of what is already known; it cannot predict anything else. Whereas empiricism can discover things which are not dreamed of by a particular theory.
Even the famous examples of rationalism, such as Einstein's theory of relativity, and Maxwell's equations which predicted radio waves, were based on empirical observations: that the speed of light appears to be constant in all directions (inconsistent with an ether); and Faraday's observation that a magnetic field can affect the polarization of light, respectively.
Excessive rationalism is popular in software researchers, but it is not appropriate for any software that interacts with reality - as all useful software does.
I don't know exactly what those individuals meant by "absolutely not", however I'm not seeing a conflict between individuals, but between attitudes (which also exists within an individual.)
When conducting research, individuals vary in their attachment to theory; even within the one researcher, there are conflicting tendencies to follow theory or to test it. I say tendencies, because there isn't a strictly rational way to know when to begin or stop a particular line of experiments. It is, by nature, unknown.
When established theory says that something definitely won't work, one is less encouraged to try the experiment. Therefore I think it's important to celebrate each new discovery - especially when it undermines a theory.
I think you have misinterpreted my comments, especially the longer one.