What Every Startup Need to Know About IP in China | Hacker News Reader

What Every Startup Need to Know About IP in China

formdevices.com

72 pointsnmattisson21 comments

Open articleView on HN

If you found this interesting, you might also like:

- http://www.chinalawblog.com/2013/09/china-trademark-basics.h...

- http://www.chinalawblog.com/2013/04/register-your-china-trad...

- http://www.chinalawblog.com/2014/04/the-trouble-with-madrid-...

- http://www.chinalawblog.com/2014/07/when-to-register-your-ch...

I'm curious about copyright infringement in china and what practical options there are. Hope it's not too OT.

We're building an anatomy learning platform[0], and produce original illustrations and videos that cost us a lot of time and money to create. When we see copies on US or EU website we can use DMCA or EU takendown notices, which usually work. In China our emails were pretty much ignored...

Now we're not some huge company, we're a small bootstrapped startup which isn't even ramen-profitable yet (mostly due to large expenses on content-creation). We cannot even afford a lawyer locally, let alone someone who can represent us in China. I'm wondering if anyone has some tips or experience in this area?

(all being said, the number of infringements we know about is pretty small, but it's worrying nonetheless)

[0] www.kenhub.com

China is many things, but one of those is practical. They're planning for a future in which they're not just a low-cost manufacuring hub (much of that is indeed already leaving China for places like Vietnam). To that end, they're making a very concerted effort to modernize their legal system, importing many ideas from the U.S. (e.g. they have American legal academics helping reform areas like the law of evidence) and introducing twists of their own (e.g. lightweight arbitration for small civil disputes).

> Chinese trademark registration costs are typical internationally.

To the OP, this sentence does not parse or I fail to understand what you mean with it.

Perhaps it's suggesting that trademark registration costs in China are on par with those of other countries?

Poorly worded perhaps, but michelmior's interpretation is correct.

Great article. Thanks for sharing your experience

Thanks for information about trademarks. What about utility, utility models and designs? Can it be protected in China?

Yes, they have a system with design and utility patents that is ~similar to the west. When you talk to local lawyers they always emphasise the importance of trademarks as the most effective way to protect your IP, but if you are have the budget getting patents could be good as well. The one thing to note is that you have to file a Chinese patent within a year of any other application worldwide. (I don't know nearly as much about this subject as I've learnt about trademarks, so caveat emptor.)

Interesting to see the tides changing. Whether the IP laws are enforced is another story.

I'm preparing to lodge a patent application in China. Not because I think it might be realistically enforceable now, but because in its lifetime the degree to which the Chinese system will enforce it is going to rise.

It's a 20-year bet on the legal trajectory of what it is going to be the largest market in the world.

Are hardware+software startups like fitbit & withings copied as well?

Yes, at the price of $13. http://www.cnet.com/news/xiaomi-to-sell-its-13-fitness-band-...

This is one of the reasons why I will probably never again do a hardware start-up.

Or at least add a barrier, like a cloud-provided service component.

Not sure how much that would help even.

Look at the Misfit Shine (http://store.misfit.com/), great product, beautiful device. Then a few weeks ago I get this in the email from DX: http://www.dx.com/p/otium-shine-1-1-ipx7-bluetooth-v4-0-smar...

It is obviously the same product, they are even using the same marketing photos.

Now here is the twist, they sort of did their own hacked version of the Shine App, and even released it to the AppStore.

Lemme give you a counter example. Chinese copied Neato or irobot Roomba, their hardware was even superior and price is 30% as much, but ultimately failed as a product. Because the route planing algorithm is completely shit. You often found it stuck or running out of power.

Neato or iRobot does not sell in China, Chinese users actually pays extra to get one. And they are happily doing so.

The moral of the story? Chinese can not copy the soul of your product.

Kindof surprising that they did not manage to obtain the routing algorithm of the Roomba.

Very helpful and something we have worried about as well.

Very helpful - thanks!

nice

Reply on news.ycombinator.com