Is TOMS “selling out” for profit? And why does this bother us?
joycorps.org
joycorps.org
Throwing free shoes at these markets shuts down the people trying to make a living for themselves making shoes. We're not talking about software here, it doesn't take a great deal of skill or resources to make shoes. 2/3rds of readers' clothing here probably comes out of the developing markets that Tom's floods.
I will consider Tom's a "charitable organization" when they build and hand over ownership of factories and farms for free.
I'm still interested in the concept that a company could be good, rather than focused purely on increasing wealth for owners and shareholders. It's possible, yet rare, so there must be something fundamental that's driving these results.
What if we could change it?
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercantilism
Furthermore, if a country has little-to-no access to electricity, providing it is unlikely to impact anyone negatively. And besides, workers/citizens/the state ought own the utilities; this is the case in most of the world and I've had nothing but crap experiences with the privately owned kind.
Are you going to dump seeds and irrigation systems into the same bucket as free shoes too?
Sure, choosing what to charitably give without causing more harm than good must be done carefully, I'll give you that, but I'm not following the all-or-nothing extension of that argument.