Prices have value, and people should have the right to be coy about what they'll accept. A domain squatter's activities may be sleazy and borderline-illegal, but they have the same rights as someone at an auction whose reserve price is a secret, and who may well refuse the offer of the successful bidder.
And does it really matter anymore? Apparently we have 276 million registered domains [1] and when 2012 numbers were released [2]:
About 21 percent of .com and .net websites, by the
way, are just one-page sites and 15 percent are
registered but don’t point to a working site at all.
I think that 21% includes squatters on top of which .com+.net are only ~50% of total domains.[1] http://www.verisigninc.com/en_US/innovation/dnib/index.xhtml
[2] http://techcrunch.com/2013/04/08/internet-passes-250m-regist...
It seems that domain squatting (cybersquatting) is illegal in some circumstances:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cybersquatting
> And does it really matter anymore?
Yes, of course. No matter now many registered domain names there are, names that match copyrighted or trademarked words are still a matter of great interest to cybersquatters.
Of course they are -- all one need do is read the article I linked, which describes how cybersquatters sit on names of established companies or trademarks, until someone tries to pay their ransom. Many such cases end up in court, because that kind of cybersquatting is illegal.