Junk science is putting innocent people in jail
economist.com
economist.com
And there's no excuse for a prosecutor trying to pressure an innocent victim into pleading guilty - they sent an innocent person to prison and possibly allowed the real murderer to keep on killing people. Unfortunately, this happens all the time.
The problem is when the junk science makes everyone convinced of guilt. Once that happens, nothing good is going to happen.
That cynicism translates back into broader society and causes antipathy if not hostility in the general public towards the police. The whole thing creates much more harm than good.
We were instructed to not speak to the other jurors during the trial, but I had already decided that a stern looking oil and gas attorney on the jury would end up being a law-and-order throw-the-book-at-them type. Once we got into the jury room to decide the sentence I realized how wrong I was. Our first vote was 2 for acquittal (me and the attorney) and the rest leaning towards guilty.
The trial wasn't complicated, but I was alarmed that most of the jury had a very poor understanding of the evidence presented. I heard reasoning such as the following: "Well, I'm a Mom and I'm just very very against drunk driving." OK, but what the hell has that got to do with the evidence we heard? There were serious problems with the evidence presented and it took a couple of hours of discussion before it we eventually settled on not guilty.
Years later a lawyer here explained to me why the compositions of the juries is so frightening. The juror pool used to come from local property tax records. This was decided to be unrepresentative of the population and they moved to pools based on driving license records. Anyone with a driving license can end up as a juror. Many of the people that don't come up with excuses for why they shouldn't take a week away from work are those that you wouldn't trust with any kind of important decision.
I don't know how to fix this.
Well, an unlimited number can be dismissed for cause, and the prosecution and the defense have, on top of that, a limited number that each can unilaterally dismiss without cause (peremptory challenges.)
Worth watching
Edit: I think it's because I blocked cookies from them a while back when I got paywalled before.