Westphalia. Beige dictatorship. Cute. But please don't apply your favorite cookie cutters to a deep and complex issue and tell me they slice it just the way it needs to be sliced.
Westphalia. Beige dictatorship. Cute. But please don't apply your favorite cookie cutters to a deep and complex issue and tell me they slice it just the way it needs to be sliced.
I think the point about the ideal size of a state being closer to Scotland's population than to the UK's is a reasonable, fundamental contribution to the debate. It's not a 'cookie-cutter' argument. People are right to think in fundamental, philosophical terms.
As the referendum draws closer I find myself paying less and less attention to short-term issues (which are mostly just quibbles over SNP policies, which really don't have much to do with independence - we could get independence then elect a different party) and thinking more along fundamental lines. One thing I'm sad not to have seen much discussion on is the constitution for an independent Scottish state. That to me is vitally important from a historical perspective.
I don't know where the Scottish equivalent of the Bill of Rights would come from.
In terms of the SNP, what happens to them in an independent Scotland might be the most interesting thing. They'd undoubtedly do well in a first election but after the glow has worn off and without their current USP (independence, the only party which is just about Scotland) it'll be interesting to see how they define themselves - after all, politically it's not impossible to view them as to the right of the Labour party (they're not the Tories but they're certainly not socialists), and in another few years time they're going to be very much part of the establishment.
Neither of them are quite European heavyweights but ultimately , unless there is some sort of fudge (not impossible but unlikely), every existing EU nation will have to vote to accept an independent Scotland. For that to happen it would appear that something will have to be done to placate those with similar potential domestic issues themselves if it's too happen. Whether of not such a something realistically exists or not I don't know.
I'd argue that where is Scotland's economic power base going to come from, and what sort of economic freedom will they actually get[1] is a much more fundamental, long term issue than the present set of Westminster politicians being uninspiring careerist with a lack of radical ideas, which this article discusses at great length. For better or worse a similarly sized and distributed UK electorate produced much more conviction politics and polarisation in the 70s and 80s. As for the consensus politics, the only guaranteed outcome of the referendum is that 40-49% of the electorate is going to be bitterly disappointed.
Even the arcane philosophical question of the present level of devolution waters down the allegedly-obsolete Westphalian system whereas a fully independent Scotland freed from any Westminster tinkering reestablishes it[2] is open for debate.
[1]The only problem I have with the debate about whether Scotland will be economically better off is that neither side is willing to openly admit the most likely outcome of post-independence negotiations (Holyrood ceding rather a lot of oil revenue and fiscal handcuffs for formal currency union in the form of token representation on the Bank of England's committees)
[2]The actual Westphalian treaty, amongst other things, established the formal independence of the Netherlands and Switzerland from larger empires
Welcome to the Scottish independence debate.
On one level it's been extraordinary - pretty much everyone has an opinion and the turnout rate is likely to be 80%+. On a more depressing level the quality of the debate and information made available has largely been extraordinarily poor.
In this case, we don't have any choice. People are voting, they're voting about changes, and they're voting about changes now, so it's good to see that people are coming up with original thoughts, because this aggregation of opinions is the only solution available to human society -- nobody, not Alfred Wohlstetter, not Noam Chomsky, not even Ludwig Wittgenstein -- knows what the world will look like in 200 years, and really, there isn't any[2] scientific knowledge on how borders ought to be drawn.
"If you don't know how to vote, vote for nothing" -- this impulse will be the death of democracy. Simple ideas are better than no ideas; intuition is worse than reason but still better than nothing.
The opinion I am espousing in this post stands in direct contrast to many previous arguments where I called for rigor and caution. This is because I think elections are a fundamentally different process than top-down policies: an election needs to incorporate the information possessed by every individual in the society, if I'm working for the NSA and -- even if I have a family to support, or ideological opposition to pulling a Snowden -- if I know what we're doing is wrong I can vote against it, because the sanctity of the voting booth is the cornerstone of [every] democracy[3].
So it's also interesting to wonder if the Internet -- all this connectedness -- might lead us into social biases that would never have previously affected us. The ideas which become popular these days are the ones that you can learn about in five minutes.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wisdom_of_the_crowd#Problems
[2] it's not rigorous
[3] http://www.tv.com/m/shows/the-wire/margin-of-error-898885/tr...