Reddit is a failed state
theverge.com
theverge.com
The degree of detail of personal information that we post online if someone resourceful enough like a reporter at WashPo can gather on ourselves, both our public or pseudo-anonymous personas truly reveal everything about our professional, psychological, financial and personal lives.
Recently, two events happened to me where I was confronted with IRL with what I said online which I thought was anonymous. I felt really uncomfortable initially because I felt simultaneously really rude to the people who have read my comments because it was my pure unadulterated thoughts without any real life filter; and exposed because there are honest thoughts of mine like stream-of-conscious thoughts that I'd never express in public to communicate to someone else, kind of like Jimmy Carter who answered "Yes, in my thoughts" to the question of "Have you ever cheated on your wife."
Going back to the main topic of discussion, if I was exposed to the core by WashPo, I'd be no better johnmcjohn. But like johnmcjohn who made his profile public again on Twitter because "there is nothing to hide," I feel honesty in all shapes of forms, even if it exposes you as a 33-year old guy with a questionable personal/professional background who shares celeb nudies is the way to go.
I post a lot of provocative comments on this forum; the first few times, it was because I felt arrogant or wanted to attack some of the people-types whom I disliked in real life online. But after someone replied to one of my comment and gave a good counter-perspective and made me learn new things and new perspective. It made me not afraid to be downvoted and keep being honest. I hope that more confrontations and humiliations come my way, so that I can learn from them.
But you did!
That's sort of the whole point here. So if you do it because you think you are anonymous (as in your identity is divorced from what you say) but it is stuff that you'd never express in public then you have essentially crossed one of your own rules. You shouldn't say/do stuff anonymously that you would not say/do when you're identified.
Sometimes it is the other way around that our real identity is divorced from what we have to present in public. There are different personalities who choose to use different means of communication - I know that preferred mode of communication on HN is to offer advice/encouragement/feedback to others' startups and technical/business career paths etc. like at a real life tech meetup's.
But I gravitate the personalities of people's throwaway confessions of their burnouts, private frustrations and rants against the industry that quite often reveal more their personal vulnerabilities (which is universal in the introvert/geek culture) than technical matters (e.g., michaelochurch).
Other people might take issue or feel personally outraged or just amused. But I don't use this forum with my real life handle/LinkedIn to build my "network," but as a way to express personal thoughts and get feedback from others relating to similar issues - which a lot of people do as well do (e.g., keeping a personal journal).
So I think that's where the mismatched expectations comes from.
Link-dumps and fora in general could do a lot more to protect the privacy of victims, there are whole websites dedicated to doing harm to others, usually people who had absolutely no idea that the innocent picture they took or allowed to be taken would end up online some day to ruin their lives or cause them at a minimum great distress.
I've been battling this problem for years, and even 'consenting adults' can get themselves into a ton of trouble if they do not oversee all the possible consequences of their actions.
It's the main reason why I've decided to ban all forms of nudity on my website, even though I personally believe that people should be able to do whatever they want in the privacy of their own homes, and by extension their own homes on the net the amount of grief that can come of it nullifies any positive effects.
Reddit could and should do more to stop abuses like these and hiding behind the 'free speech' banner when clearly the images distributed were distributed without the consent and probably even the knowledge of the subjects of the images is cheap and tone-deaf.
Which is a pity because reddit is one of very few sites on the net that has very long term potential.
I am not sure what people are asking for: Do they want reddit to start censoring more stuff? That can quickly become a slippery slope. Do they want reddit to break DMCA laws? That's not going to happen. Do they want reddit to fall on its sword and censor nothing even if it means the demonization of reddit? Probably a bad idea too.
On another note, I mostly use reddit to read /r/cpp, /r/netsec, /r/Iceland, /r/hiphopheads, /r/bourbon (and friends), /r/LosAngeles, and a collection of other interest specific subreddits. I barely noticed the recent shenanigans. When an article attempts to paint reddit as "being filled with [insert broad brush here]" I always cringe; any large site cuts across most demographics. It's filled with the same type of people who use the internet; that is, the same that are walking around in your city right now. It's filled with everyone.
Imagine a HN thread about how and where you can download pirated copies of software you wrote or something similar. Do you feel that shutting that down would inhibit your freedom of speech somehow?
> We uphold the ideal of free speech on reddit as much as possible not because we are legally bound to, but because we believe that you - the user - has the right to choose between right and wrong, good and evil, and that it is your responsibility to do so. When you know something is right, you should choose to do it. But as much as possible, we will not force you to do it.
from the recent blog-post: http://www.redditblog.com/2014/09/every-man-is-responsible-f...
Once you have been made aware that a part of your infrastructure is being used to perpetrate something illegal then you should act. If you don't then you will carry some liability.
I honestly hope that Reddit gets sued for this, and loses, badly. I love the site for the communities I'm a part of, but as long as they have this attitude of 'I didn't do it, so it's not my problem', things are only going to get worse.
Do we think that the principle of freedom of speech is a good thing? And if so, shouldn't we attempt to make it available even in situations in which we are not compelled by law?
HN takes a very active role in curating discussions, and PG has made it clear why--HN serves a very specific purpose and needs to be kept on track. Reddit, on the other hand, seeks to be the "digital commons", and a broad allowance for speech is appropriate there.
So much for that principle.
If you're arguing that we should protect the freedom of speech of people who went ridiculously far out of their way to continue to share illegally obtained, private pictures, and then blame the victims for everything that's happened to them, I can't agree.
http://www.theverge.com/2012/10/16/3514232/reddit-ceo-yishan...
> Last week, that very same Gawker unmasked one of Reddit's most unsavory trolls, posting his real identity for all to see. Allegedly, it cost Violentacrez his job. For Reddit, the stories were serious offenses: the site does not permit posting the personal information of its users (aka "doxxing"). However, Reddit's moderators took the rules a step further, attempting a site-wide ban against the Gawker network, and banning a user and even one fellow moderator who spoke out against such practices.
but not take down the private celebrity photos?
1. Anything goes
2. Unless it causes immediate and obvious harm to Reddit
I think the mission statements from Reddit's CEO are a torturous attempt to construct a grand community vision that embodies these laws. He might say it's the other way around, and the laws grew out of the vision, but I think these laws are shaped mainly by the economic and business realities of managing a huge community on an understaffed shoestring.
regardless, the reasons were detailed here: http://redd.it/2fpdax, it was a multitude of issues and it even surprised some reddit admins
Edit: and legally that puts them in some risk.
I would rather have reddit shut down than have it become a haven for this sort of depraved, childish, entitled, antisocial bullshit.
Reddit doesn't host the images. It is as culpable as Google.
There is a huge difference there and if Reddit turns out to have liability I wouldn't be too surprised.
In that sense they are no better than camcap forums.
Sure there's no Google Group (not just a Usenet group) dedicated to hosting such images? Or a Blogger site that does similar?