http://bellringer187868.wordpress.com/2009/07/25/the-bingo-b...
http://bellringer187868.wordpress.com/2009/07/25/the-bingo-b...
Taiwan's stock and futures exchanges have a vaguely similar trading mechanism. This isn't really well-discussed on the internet in English. Best I could find at short notice was these papers (first one free, second one not): http://www.kfunigraz.ac.at/sor/Downloads/SS2009/ExpVerfahren... http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/journal/116327547/abstrac...
Basically, instead of having continuous trading (which could mean huge amounts of market data every second), they just do 30-second auctions all day long. You get an order book update, send in your orders, and they figure out who matched whom 30 seconds later. At which point they send out the next order book update, consisting of all the orders which didn't match in the last auction. Time priority still applies within the 30-second chunks. So if you have a trading algorithm, it only has to wake up once every 30 seconds ... but when it does, it has to be fast.
(However, time priority doesn't apply in the opening auction --- the priority for orders at any given price is randomised and has nothing to do with who got their orders in first.)
Of course the little local brokers loved this mechanism, and the big foreign banks all hated it (and probably lobbied against it behind the scenes). Maybe they lobbied so hard that they don't have this mechanism anymore; I've been out of the industry for a few years now so I'm way behind the times ...
This isn't flash trading, this is just high frequency trading. All the stuff mentioned in this paragraph about "cheating" has nothing at all to do with flash orders. bellringer seems to suggest that high frequency trading is "cheating". This argument that guys with faster computers and better connections are beating at home traders is nonsensical. If I tried making cars at home in my garage, of course Toyota is going to beat me. They have state of the art factories, trained engineers, and years of experience. Toyota isn't cheating. Similarly, Goldman Sachs, along with lots of smaller guys, has huge computing clusters, blazingly fast and connections and they're going to beat you, a guy with a laptop at home. But it's not cheating.
Cheap cars are useful. A super liquid stockmarket is a zero sum game in which everyone is encouraged to participate but a few sharks basically have extra cards.
Its really not obvious why such a responsive market is necessary, it is simply said to be a good thing and a progression, yet it moves at speeds that clearly do not reflect the underlying fundamentals.
Trading = Zero-Sum.
Investing != Zero-SumThen the second part is wrong also, as the low frequency traders will lose money, getting on average worse deals. The high frequency traders will make sure you get a worse price, because any price spike you may have fortuitously gotten will be removed. Alternatively you can just reason that the high freq traders are costing money (using resources, making profits) and ergo must be extracting money out of the market.
You'll have to make a much better case for the value for such liquidity.
this is true, but "fortuitously" doesn't always apply. "price spikes" could be high or low, and could affect you positively or negatively. with out high frequency traders, it's equally likely that you get a fortuitous or unfortuitous spike. what high frequency traders do is even out prices so that they are always "right". they ensure that when you trade, you aren't trading on some random spike and are instead trading at the correct market price. despite what you think, real low to medium frequency traders enjoy having correct market prices at all times, which is what high frequency guys ensure.
Your notion of the existence of a precise right/correct price for anything is an illusion, forget about it,
This is why it is best to start with big picture reasoning - in this case that they make money and ergo others lose/make less in a zero sum market with only tangential impact on real economic activity.
Secondly, anyone who wants to can do this, they just need to pay the fee. There is zero evidence of a cartel.