Ivy League Grade Inflation
economist.com
economist.com
The logic of this was that the engineering schools of UCs had a serious "weed out" process. If you went to an Ivy and made your major CS, because it was fashionable, you got through no matter what.
I don't have anecdotes to verify this-- much less data-- but I thought it was an interesting observation.
Hmmm, my vague and out of date memory is that public universities are well represented in 2nd tier CS programs, and I can't remember any Ivies in that list. But that's old, iffy and perhaps obsolete info.
One very obsolete thing is equipment: the wealthier schools used to have a big advantage in being able to supply computer time to their students.
How do you define "top CS program"? I can't find a ranking that doesn't have Cornell or Princeton in the top 10. Defining "top program" as top 5 seems a bit odd (even then Cornell occasionally makes the list)
I'm willing to believe, maybe back then, but especially today, that some Ivy's are ranked high in the 2nd tier.
I haven't seen any data on grade inflation from non-top-tier universities. I would wager that if we're looking at second-tier (non-Ivy but still very restrictive), top-tier technical (engineering, etc.) and art/music schools, we would be seeing significantly less grade inflation.
Does anyone know if there is any data on this?
For example, I would guess that in fields in which grading can be more objective (consider the question of whether a computer program performs to spec vs. grading an analysis of some kind of literature), consistency in grading would be easier to maintain.
Then there are considerations of what grading is for. If we consider grades to be certification that a student meets the standards of a profession, then majors leading to professions with lax standards might give higher grades.
However, it's also possible I'm just worse at the harder science, and better in courses which require qualitative high performance. Another student could have the opposite effect.
If the point of grades is to sort students then sure, grades are "inflated" in that they don't accurately reflect increasingly fine distinctions in intelligence or effort. But if grades are supposed to reflect how well students understand the material on some sort of remotely absolute scale then we should expect to see average grades going up over time.