Doesn't perfect also depend on what you're trying to do?
It's all trade offs but as we increase what we do with our phones, a bigger screen potentially becomes more valuable.
I know a lot of people saying they have no interest in more than 3.5" or 4". Generally those people are fairly casual users. I also know "power users" (horrible term) who have been crying out for bigger screens.
I'm less worried about thumb size and more worried about how it feels in my pocket.