A German Car That Was Ultra-Aerodynamic and Totally Impractical
wired.com
wired.com
For example, the Prius has a frontal area of about 2.3 m², giving a CdA of 0.58 m². The Schlörwagen has a frontal area of closer to 2.8 m² (thanks to its nearly 7-foot width), giving a CdA of 0.42 m². Still better, but not 40% better like Cd alone would lead one to believe. (The original Insight, for reference, has a CdA of 0.47 m².)
The wikipedia article [1] mentions the "reference area" is part of the equation to calculate Cd.
My understanding was the the Cd is taking into consideration the area in question, that's why it's a "coefficient" [2] If it's not taking into consideration the area, surely then it's not a "coefficient" of anything, it would just be "drag".
Also worth noting that a scale model of something (plane, auto, whatever) has the same Cd as the full-size version, showing that Cd does take area into consideration.
We're not disagreeing; we understand English differently. You say "Cd does take area into consideration" to mean that area has been divided out from drag measurements to produce an area-agnostic number; I say "Cd does not take area into consideration" to mean that Cd does not vary based on area (because area has been divided out).
These are the same statements. Both underscore my point that CdA, which is (by definition!) proportional to both frontal area and to drag force, is the worthwhile figure of merit for passenger vehicles (where lesser drag force translates directly into fuel savings).
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E-ID_ktSoLY
(Part two of the video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZY7PIIV0nIs )
It later set a 143mph land speed record for a petrol-powered train, although it didn't exactly catch on (in no small part due to safety concerns concerning the passenger-mincer at the back). More here:
Here's another great example, the Mercedes T80: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercedes-Benz_T80
It was designed and built in 1939 to achieve 750km/h and very likely would have if it the war hadn't interrupted its development. It had rudimentary traction control and wings that generated downforce using the ground effect!
That 750km/h design target wasn't surpassed by a wheel driven vehicle until 2001!
For good reason; _Wages of Destruction_ covers repeatedly how concerned the German government and corporations were about how much fuel Germany needed to import, which made the country more vulnerable and exacerbated their parlous foreign-exchange/currency situation. They went to the brink repeatedly and naturally, cutting down on petroleum consumption would have been very helpful.
I can't recall the source, but there are those who posit that the international spot markets mean war never need be fought over oil supply again.
1 - http://thumbs2.ebaystatic.com/d/l225/m/mWFPlYob-ONd0k2waRJ1j...
2 - http://www.theaa.com/images/allaboutcars/testreports/2005076...
I like your comment but this seems like a total non sequitur? Are you saying that if it's not a multiway tie for the best in something, then that implies there "must be quite some room for improvement in that area"? Or how do you get to this conclusion?
It had a low drag coefficient, but there wasn't much of a practical design to maintain: "the car is so tall that a stiff crosswind could send it careening to the side."
The gains made by the Tesla S are mainly due to the form factor - it is uniquely advantaged by being a large all-electric sedan.
Longer vehicles have a significant aerodynamic advantage, because they can more closely approximate a perfect airfoil than a shorter vehicle. The Tesla S has a very smooth underbody because of the flat battery unit and because it requires no exhaust system. Air intakes are kept to a minimum, because it does not need to dissipate the copious waste heat produced by a combustion engine.
I don't mean to detract from the marvellous engineering efforts by the Tesla team, but the Model S is in a class of one. Large sedans from mainstream manufacturers come very close to the aerodynamic performance of the Model S, but the use of internal combustion puts them at an inherent disadvantage. Competing all-electric cars are predominantly cheaper and shorter vehicles, designed for the European city car market. The high price of the Model S allows Tesla to use a lot of trick aero features, like the bladed mirror mountings, active inlet vents and retractible door handles.
I have no doubt that the traditional manufacturers could match the aero performance of the Model S if they were to produce a car with a similar form factor and price; The Mercedes CLA BlueEfficiency exceeds the aerodynamic performance of the Tesla S, as one of the few large and expensive cars that have been optimised primarily for efficiency. Volkswagen manage a drag coefficient of just 0.159 with the XL1, but it costs $146,000.
This statement in the article is odd to me. It's no taller than many modern vehicles, nor is the frontal aspect ratio as bad as say, a SUV. It seems like the side stability has more to do with the wheel placement or suspension, or maybe weight balance.
It was certainly not because it was too tall.
Volkswagen XL1, a production car, has a drag coefficient of 0.189.
If you look at the modern experimental cars, they have much lower drag coefficients, like Aurora 101 is 0.08.
How do any of those things affect aerodynamics? Maybe power windows require a slightly different window design...but even that seems unlikely.
It's pretty damn hard to build a practical and safe car with a very low drag.
The original 1.3 liter car (chassis code AE532) had an EPA Highway mileage rating of 52 miles per gallon (MPG)in 1984 and was reported to often achieve over 70 MPG in favorable driving conditions
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yGNaEDAooBI&feature=youtu.be...
http://www.webroad.ch/monotracer/
Coincidence that it is also Swiss? Are these designs somehow related?
The monotracer actually exists by the way. Quite a few have been built and sold.
The Italians used a similar concept (forward control, teardrop shape) for their Fiat 600 Multipla.
Smaller and not quite as aerodynamic, but nevertheless it was shipped, and widely used as taxis which proves its versatility.
Not sure why, but I just love the teardrop concept. No matter how flat and squared the front of the vehicle, add a taper to the rear and all's well with airflow.