Why Reddit is mediocre: some scientific evidence
washingtonpost.com
washingtonpost.com
>Leskovec and his colleagues don’t look at Reddit, but instead at four other prominent information-sharing Web sites with roughly similar mechanics (these sites, like Reddit, allow users to “upvote,” or “downvote” posts and comments).
The paper compares CNN.com (general news), Breitbart.com (political news), IGN.com(computer gaming), and Allkpop.com which are all completely different from Reddit.
>(1) People who write low quality posts are more likely to write again when they get negative attention. Furthermore, the quality of their posts deteriorates.
Simply not true. Posts that are downvoted dissappear (getting downvoted 'into oblivion'). This discourages shitposting.
>(2) People who write high quality posts are encouraged by positive attention to write more.
Not entirely true either. Posts that are 'popular' get upvoted. Posts that get upvoted get upvoted. Often these are made up anecdotes, or quick witty jokes, wordplays, quick digestible fluff. The whole gilding thing makes it worse (sometimes).
>This may help explain why so many of Reddit’s subreddits are dominated by bigots, misogynists and other people who appear to thrive on public abhorrence.
Ooh so that's what this article was all about ...
You are backing up your statements of fact with arguments about how it's naively supposed to work, assuming rational actors.
Do you have any actual evidence other than "this is how I want people to behave"? Because the findings of the study seem very plausible to me. And your idea that trolls get discouraged because of downvotes and hiding seems to completely ignore reality.
You do get a few people who feel validated by the downvotes. This sometimes happens on HN.
Also, Sub-reddits vary from sub to sub, poor moderation. You cannot drag all of them into it just because one screws up.
This is a fluff piece.
To be clear: The article bases its analysis of Reddit on the study,[1] which examines the communities named above but does not mention Reddit.
[1] http://cs.stanford.edu/people/jure/pubs/disqus-icwsm14.pdf