Let me guess: are you a young, idealistic intellectual? What position does fitness of the community occupy in that world view?
QED
If the former, demanding a vigorous defense is clearly counterproductive. Anything anyone posts would find more people leaping to object than affirm, unless it happens to be a point this crowd happens to hold that particular contrarian viewpoint.
If the latter, the usefulness of such challenge likely depends on how well other readers are expected to do at assessing veracity themselves.
Personally, I find it valuable to read clear statements of positions I disagree with, and would weakly rather this thread promote such - there are plenty of threads that are better places to argue the meat of things.