The truth is that notes and YC's SAFE are still the way to go. Why? If the startup is taking off, then you're going to blow past your cap (which you should set fairly) and everyone's happy. If the startup isn't headed anywhere, well, why the hell are you raising more anyway? Consider selling or shutting it down. The problems he's pointing out apply in this case, and frankly you can always in such a situation consider re-negotiating prior deals if you have to. In other words, these are theoretical objections at best.
Most 'traditional' investors used to have it good in the (good, according to them) old days. They had the leverage, so they forced terms that were good for them. This meant lower valuations in general compared to today, and control in the form of board seats, which you generally had to have once you had different classes of equity. Those days are long gone, and this strikes me as a lament for the way things used to be.