Far from speculative - it's a rather straightforward result from the basic economic principles at play. And even if you hesitate to draw conclusions based on reasoning from first principles alone (which you should), there have been a few studies which have measured this effect empirically.
Keep in mind that the economic impact of hotels (both illegal and legal) on nearby rent has been well studied[0], so unless there is a reason to believe that Airbnb specifically is unique, the default assumption should be that they will have this effect too.
It's not a smoking gun, no, but it's far from speculative if both inductive and deductive reasoning support that conclusion.
[0] Especially zoning, which is a distinct but very related issue.