Subway history: Don't be early
blogs.law.harvard.edu
blogs.law.harvard.edu
> Yup. American visitors to Europe + UK often marvel at the efficient passenger railway system and wonder why the US can’t build something similar, without understanding the history of how they were built. In the 1800s early investors/inventors went through a railway mania, grossly overbuilt, and went bankrupt. The good lines were later scooped up for a fraction of their original cost by a 2nd round of investors, and morphed into today’s system. It was never economically feasible to build a passenger railway system without first wiping out the “too early” investors.
So while being too early pretty much guarantees failure, it seems we might need those early people. Perhaps the recipe for an truly innovative society necessarily includes over-encouragement of bleeding-edge innovator types. These will almost certainly fail; however, in failing, they allow later businesses to succeed.
Readers are invited to consider what role Y Combinator might play in this process. :-)
A huge fraction of people now have solar panels on their roof, but now there's no longer a business incentive for sustainable production of solar panels (i.e. advancements in some technology that would make them cost-effective), because the market is now saturated. Additionally, these solar panels may well be displacing other next-generation energy technologies because of the artificially low price, even if there is no advancement that would make solar power cost-effective on a reasonable time scale. On net, humanity had to pay the full price for all those solar panels, and once they exist we're better off using them than not, but it's not necessarily true that because we have them and they are in use, we're better off than we would be if they had never been created in the first place.
EDIT: I should clarify that I'm not sure that under investment is any better - the right amount of investment is a knowledge problem that we generally solve iteratively with feedback from the profit-loss system. It's just that just because you can reduce the total deadweight loss from over-investment doesn't mean that over-investment is somehow a good thing.
And Altavista, Lycos, Infoseek, Excite, etc. for Google.
And YouSendIt & clones for DropBox.
And Hotmail, Outlook Web Access, Y!Mail, etc. for GMail.
As an entrepreneur, it's generally much more lucrative to take other ideas that people have been playing around with and getting some modest success and then perfect them, rather than to have your own ideas.