Ah awesome -- was really hoping I didn't come off as judgemental in the comment.
Mind sharing what you ended up using? I didn't see it on the post (maybe I didn't look hard enough?).
[EDIT]
I just realized the second screen shot is the changed app...
After a quick google search I found stuff like this (the first one doesn't look bad at all): http://forum.unity3d.com/threads/gui-ngui-skins-and-widgets-...
Is that usable?