To be clear, my ding is not just against libertarianism, but against ideologies that set up shop on the endpoints of the axis that goes from "individualism" to "collectivism".
Libertarianism, while not out on the cliff edge of individualism, at least has reserved seats for a great view of it. (I'm being very careful here not to call libertarianism an "extreme" ideology, because I don't think that's a fair assessment).
There are highly collectivist ideologies way out on the other end of the axis that have entirely different, but equal structural issues (and before you say "communism" that's not necessarily what I'm thinking of).
In either case, highly individualistic or highly collectivistic ideologies almost never survive sustained contact with more moderate, pragmatic outside groups.
Survival of groups of like-minded end-point ideologists almost always require isolation-like implementation approaches because of this simple issue.
Does libertarianism "work"? Hell if I know. I think most evidence points to it not working well over sustained periods. Most "pure" ideologies don't, and the more "pure" the ideology, the less likely it is to be able to sustain itself, even superficially, on the tenants of its core concepts for long. The world is just too messy and libertarianism is just not road tested enough to have figured out what really doesn't work and adjust.
A fully implemented, fully sustaining, libertarian paradise would likely not be much like present day libertarian ideological tenants, but something more moderate in approach, and it might not even be superficially much different than regimes it would be replacing...the differences would be more in small details and guiding philosophy than in more noticeable things.