I've been to NYTM and while Nate is doing a great job, I think it's still too big and represents more of the 'business entrepreneur' community than the 'engineer' community.
The Hackers & Founders meetup that Dave (http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=daveambrose) runs is a lot more interesting but smaller and does not have demo's.
Maybe I'm just out of it but the NY tech community feels a lot more fragmented than the one out on the west coast.