I have to disagree. A trained mathematician understands why a proof is or it not valid, based on a combination of axioms and a logical sequence predicated on axioms, but with no gaps or overlooked assumptions.
Without knowing and explaining why, it would not be possible to write a proof that would pass muster with other mathematicians, people who by instinct and training refuse to accept fuzzy explanations.
This is why Gödel's Incompleteness Theorems came as such a shock, at a time when many people expected to be able to systematize all of mathematics and predicate it on a handful of unassailable logical principles (as Russell and Whitehead attempted to do in the early 20th century).
The Incompleteness Theorems show the degree to which mathematicians expect to know why something is true, and if they cannot, why not.