As for me, personally, I think CEO's response was exactly what it should be. Honest, clear, straight to the point. Reddit just earned my respect as a workplace.
As for me, personally, I think CEO's response was exactly what it should be. Honest, clear, straight to the point. Reddit just earned my respect as a workplace.
Ideas of professionalism relate to professions and as far as I'm concerned, if reddit is this man's profession, well, that's just par for the course, isn't it?
I might have the same demeanor in this regard as yishan and if that means people think I'm not CEO material, so be it -- but I believe there are many people out there who value this down-to-Earth, human-driven approach (Hard to find the right words for it; You know what I mean).
Of course, these two situations aren't the same. I still find their respective rhetorics interesting.
The short answer is HN values the top contrarian voice regardless of which side is actually in the right.
* "Childish" and "unprofessional" are not synonyms.
* Neither are "adult" and "professional".
* Neither are "childish" and "honest".
* Neither are "adult" and "dishonest".
* PR fluff is not the same as the general concept of public relations.
* "We will not discuss this." is honest and straightforward, as are a number of alternative statements people have suggested.
* A statement made by an individual with limited power and resources may have very different implications and be perceived very differently than the same statement made by one with great power and resources.
* HN is composed of many individuals with nuanced opinions and worldviews.
* Individuals with diametrically opposed viewpoints in some areas may have very similar viewpoints in others, and sometimes the reasons for that may be subtle.
* No particular comment thread will necessarily have a representative sample of individuals participating.
* Confirmation bias exists.
FWIW, "Childish" and "unprofessional" can arguably be used interchangeably in this case since they both present the concept of acting in contrast to the social norm of the group (adults & professionals), though their dictionary definitions are far from synonyms.
These are not semantic nitpicks. They have much deeper meaning. I cannot stop you from dismissing them, but I hope you will consider them more than you have.
But I guess in this case, the most relevant conclusion would be that people whining about unprofessionalism and people whining about professionalism are two different groups; usually one speaks up and the other stays silent.