Hacker News Reader

Legally speaking a 5 second clip is fine but a 20 second clip is beginning to push it and several of them from the same franchise... I'm not saying it should be this way btu the fx in a movie is a form of art and thus can be copyrighted, not just the plot and other aspects of the movie.

View on HN

I am not a lawyer, but I'm pretty sure that ideas about how long something can be and still be fair use are more internet rules of wisdom than they are anything else.

Of course it matters if you are only using a portion of a work, but the context the work is being used in is a lot more important than counting the seconds.

"Legally speaking" a five second clip can be copyright infringement while a 20 second clip is "fine". length of time, in terms of fair use, has to do with the overall length of the copyrighted subject. I haven't seen the video but based on the description it seems to fall squarely under the fair use terms.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com