RMS: De Icaza Traitor to Free Software Community
osnews.com
osnews.com
The existence of free/open source software owes a big debt to RMS's idealogical extremism, and Emacs, GCC and GNU are pretty major (and admirable) achievements in programming. That's why I say I admire RMS, even if I wouldn't want him to date my sister.
Miguel de Icaza never got over his incapacity to land a job at MS (it was no visa because he didn't have a degree it wasn't because he was stupid) and has always sought to emulate them and defend them from that point onwards in some weird psychological relationship. Novell is suspicious in its intentions and it seems they'd gladly see others get sued if they had a waiver. They are not a community player at all.
Miguel putting "God" and "Love" in his post he doesn't clear up any of the issues while he sits there trying to evoke an open source hero mystique while working on a Microsoft platform clone... for the iPhone.
What the hell does this mean? It's not a crime to be a monopoly!
It's like saying someone who broke laws during the civil rights era, to integrate their establishments etc... being convicted of a bad law is meaningless.
were you in the software business circa 1992? quite a few companies who thought they were creating good businesses for themselves were in fact doing market research for microsoft, to mangle something pg said in one of his essays. microsoft's antics managed to retard software innovation for a good long while. i, for one, am glad they are no longer the unstoppable juggernaut they once were.
Please use the correct terms to describe things.
How are these facts changed by the case being brought before the court as a civil action?
No. A crime is an act in violation of criminal law. From wiki (apologies in advance) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime -- "While every crime violates the law, not every violation of the law counts as a crime."
i chose the word "crime" because the comment i was replying to used it.
The word crime has very different connotations for me than the words civil suit do, and it really disturbs me when people substitute one for the other. Let's reserve the word crime for acts like rape and murder, please.
Your mention of murder down-thread is an excellent example, as someone can commit an act of murder and face a criminal murder trial and/or a civil "wrongful death" case. O.J. Simpson is a famous, high-profile example of this.
You are basically taking the same position that his P.R. people might: that since he was acquitted in the criminal case, he is not a criminal - even though he lost the civil case. Yes, in the "innocent until proven guilty" sense of the word "criminal", you and they have an excellent technical point.
But you and they would have us to believe that O.J. actually committed no crime, and that might work on anyone who does not reserve the right to draw a distinction between having committed a crime and having been convicted of it.
Back to Microsoft, ask yourself what the Sherman Act is: is it civil law or criminal law? As it happens, the Sherman Act includes both criminal and civil remedies for violations. That is why, for example, books like this exist...
http://www.amazon.com/Criminal-Antitrust-Litigation-Handbook...
The DoJ pressed the matter as a civil action. This doesn't mean that Microsoft's violations were merely civil violations. Rather, it means that the civil violations were the ones that were successfully prosecuted. Whether or not their violations were also criminal in nature is a question that was never pursued.
So, yeah, Microsoft's actions were non-criminal an an O.J. kind of way. I'll give you that.
Clearly not. However, if a court hasn't decided on the matter, whether the act is criminal or not is at least partly a value judgment. My value judgment is that while Microsoft did a lot of horrible stuff in the '90s, none of it warrants the tag "criminal".
By that definition, Microsoft was never convicted, since it was never accused of a crime. Microsoft was tried in civil court.
This so far has been a community that prides itself on accuracy. If you're going to accuse someone of criminal acts, they should at least have been tried and found guilty in criminal court.
It only captures it if the EU considers it to be a crime. Does it? (genuinely curious)
Wiktionary definition: "A specific act committed in violation of the law." Wikipedia (the sentence before you earlier nitpick quote): "Crime is the breach of one or more rules or laws for which some governing authority, via mechanisms such as police power, may ultimately prescribe a conviction." Wordnet: " an act punishable by law; usually considered an evil act" and "an evil act not necessarily punishable by law"
N.B. The definitions from Wordnet, my uses passes BOTH. So it seems that if a governing body passes a law or regulation against a certain activity and then the government (through whatever process) finds someone in violation and sanctions them, you don't want to call it a crime (despite this being well within the broadest definitions), you want to have a big cry. Well sorry buddy, this isn't a court of law, this is the English language. You are the reason people hate lawyers.
You conveniently elided the part that says "(criminal law)" before that. Who's the one being intellectually dishonest here?
> and "an evil act not necessarily punishable by law" ... my uses passes BOTH
Great, you made a value judgment. I disagree with your value judgment. I don't think Microsoft's actions were evil enough to be called crimes.
The guy has been proven to behave like an asshole, but i find it good to judge people on what they do. The contribution of miguel , in usefulness for a regular Linux user experience today ,is certainly comparable to RMS's.
And while i, like many others ,am very suspicious about the mono story, i would really like like to see this project succeed, if only because there is IMHO a desperate need for a decent multi-language VM on linux (other than java, wich is pretty unusable for desktop applications on linux).
Also, the patents infrigement threat has been hanging on diverse parts of GNU/linux for a very long time, and i've yet to be convinced of the solidity of the case microsoft could have against mono, since after everything i've read i couldn't reach a clear conclusion.
So yeah, RMS is true to himself. But i don't find that admirable at all. There is no balance in what he says, ever, and i don't view that as genius ...
I don't want to live in his free software world, because he looks like a totalitarian. Even if his views and his works are to be valuated, i respectfully disagree with him on almost anything ideological. And i don't like people insulting others in public, for any reasons ..
Like if i was watching a movie, i have real huge problems picturing miguel in the position of the ugly traitor, sorry ...
1. Miguel de Icaza, after a secret deal with microsoft and novell, starts an OSS implementation of the dot net platform. It has been his goal from the beginning. In fact he always wanted to work at Microsoft, and he decided to become their infiltrated spy, to stop the worst threat Microsoft has ever seen : Linux (ahem, sorry ,i mean GNU/Linux). Some say that's even why he started GNOME in the first place.
2. He gets a lot of contributors, but that's mainly because they're too dumb to see the secret plan he has from the beginning.
3. The mono platform enters a stage in wich it becomes usable, and applications begin to appear and after some time, begin to become integrated into common linux distributions. The fact that Novell is actually developping a major linux distro is a big factor in this.
4. Some very clever OSS users / programmers / developpers, led by their enlightened guru Richard Stallman, finally discover that this is a secret plan to make the whole GNU/Linux stumble. They decide to put aside the quarell about the Linux name, because duty is calling them. They consequently put tremendous effort into alerting people about the menace
5. The evil duo (Microsoft / Novell) and Miguel the menial, are in a very bad position. They never expected anybody to actually SEE through their evil plan. Microsoft then decides to publish a 'promise' not to sue anybody about an implementation of the CLR. The plan is very clever, because mono implements not only the CLR, but other parts of the Microsoft stack. When things will be calmer again, then will be the moment to sue !
... are you guys serious ?
Now i know there are some real risks, some real stakes, maybe even some part of that is true. But common, when i read some contributions, i just wonder how much hollywood movies has affected our brains.
To Stallman he is a traitor to the ideals and helping the enemy (see my other post on this page). This does not mean it's a conspiracy.
"i just wonder how much hollywood movies has affected our brains". Indeed.
I appreciate all the things that rms has done, but he's gone off his rocker; why people still pay any attention to him is baffling to me (other than the tabloid qualities of paying attention to him, I suppose).
There are quite a few out there who are interested in it, but their skillset leads them to Mono
Mono is an open source-licensed project, so if a MS developer starts working in Mono, aren't they effectively working with Open source??GNOME breathed fresh air into the Unix workstation and made it truly a commodity.
Even Motif would have still been closed if it wasn't for the high quality code that Miguel et al where churning out both in GNOME and also in Gtk and its associated technologies.
In 2001, Ximian was the hottest thing to run on a PC. If they put a price tag on it they could have sold it in custom boxes at $5k and would have had buyers, but it was free, and it was a Unix desktop you could install and upgrade by double clicking on an icon. Fucking gorgeous too.
RMS's choice of the word traitor implies that he understands this and is only commenting on recent actions of Miguel's.
Bullshit. As if no one else could have created a linux desktop? There were already plenty of window managers at the time. The distance between a window manager and a "linux desktop" is pretty slim.
> In 2001, Ximian was the hottest thing to run on a PC. If they put a price tag on it they could have sold it in custom boxes at $5k and would have had buyers, but it was free...
And then Ximian died. Perhaps they should have sold it for $5k a box instead, hm?
There were plenty of Linux WMs but they didn't aspire to do anything more than what (fv)wm was doing and it was considered fancy to support ICCCM. X was big and bulky and it had to be accepted for what it was. Actually, most Linux users were happy with FWVM2 and other stuff, OpenLook and CDE were frowned upon as a corporate kludge, perhaps in sour grapes.
The genius of GNOME was not just the delivery of a full Free desktop, first, but also the ballsy withdrawal from everything X. GNOME said we're gonna bring our own libraries and we're gonna supplant and supersede X. They brought in a display manager, session manager, input translator, etc. They didn't stop there but they also brought unorthodox, at least to unix, computing models: they brought a component object model with CORBA/Orbit. GNOME kept pushing the boundaries and for once defining what Linux should look like, not a poor man's SysV-clone, but a new desktop OS to be judged on its own. So much so that an early port to Solaris was the hottest thing on Sunfreeware.
So what is he think that Miguel De Icaza is a traitor to HIS ideals! It's his opinion!
And, when you speak with friends, don't you ever accuse and attack anyone for something he did or said! Why isn't RMS allowed to speak his mind, and speak freely!
I believe people are too harsh on RMS and love to portrait him as psycho, weird and eccentric to the level that allow them to discredit him.
RMS is a guy of principles, let him be!
Zealots tend to do a lot of damage to projects - especially FOSS projects. And it's hard not to class Stallman as a zealot.
Nobody forbids him to speak his mind. They just think he's a jackass for making that remark. I agree. And that's my opinion and I do believe I have the same right to express that as he does.
Edit: Just noticed that Icaza also accepted to be part of MS's open source labs.
You didn't just say that!!
What really invented "Open Source" was the arrival of the Internet. There have always been people wanting to share their work freely, the Internet making that possible and cheap. Heck, researches on ARPANET collaborated openly to build the Internet. And the first open-source Unix kernel to run on top of x86 wasn't Gnu or Linux, it was 386BSD.
RMS didn't invent the people's desire to share. People have been doing that long before RMS was born ;)
That made the ecosystem serious.
Actually the first big donation to open-source by a corporation is Netscape's Mozilla. It was distributed under their own license (MPL) following the definition of "open-source" ... a definition set forth because the term "free software" had ideological connotations.
Of course the FSF did valuable legal work prior to that, and they had a model to follow when defining what "open-source" is, but it was innevitable anyway.
The "open source" movement is not RMS's. Linux may have never been so popular without the work of Miguel, or without the folks at the Apache Foundation, or without Netscape's contribution, or without the contribution of so many others.
People have different goals, motivators and ideals. We will never get rid of proprietary software unless a business model is born that is better than selling copies of software. And that won't happen soon.
So instead of spreading the "free software virus" by brute force and activism, why not invite the corporations to contribute, such that at least the development tools and platforms become more open? And that's exactly what people like Miguel are doing.
I mean, I've worked on a couple of smallish projects in dotNet, and the landscape outside Microsoft is a waistland ... the majority of third party tools and libraries are proprietary. But more and more open-source tools are starting to come out of the Mono community or from CodePlex. The dotNet community is really warming up to "open-source". And I think that's really something.
Free Software has, indeed, ideological connotations. I strongly advocate for the freedoms it defends and also for the "giving back" attitude it obliges. Free Software, by its very definition, stays free. There are no such warranties in he rest of the open-source space. OS is useful, but I don't think it's enough.
I don't think Microsoft is acting against its interests by committing to open-source. Quite the contrary.
If they open-sourced Silverlight, would they lose money from their authoring tools? What they would lose is some level of control, but they could win a big enough user-base to take on Flash, which is still king. Would I care if their authoring tools are proprietary and expensive? Not at all if they're getting the job done, as long as the platform is open.
You see, open source is really about economics, being many times a cheaper and more effective way of developing and distributing software. If you want to talk about rights with normal people, you'll have to explain those rights in terms of benefits.
Having the ability to share software with your friends is not a good incentive for many software developers. But having your piece of software maintained by others (when you don't want to die doing that) is an incentive.
And I don't think that the "giving back" attitude should be forced. It should come naturally from the inherent gains. We are so blinded by the individualism promoted by capitalism that we forget sharing and cooperation have real advantages. But being blinded by an ideology with opposites points of view is evenly shortsighted.
You see, while many people in Silicon Valley or in Cambridge are working happily in startups or on cool projects that will save the world someday, the rest of the world is kind of stuck in consultancy with flat hourly bills, working on boring and-not-quite-fulfilling projects that in many countries pays less than your average gas-station supervisor. And working on Free Software when your hourly rate is $10 an hour you can trust me it's not that great.
Another thing about open-source software is that there are clear disadvantages of the development model. You can see that in the unpolished GUIs of the open-source applications or in the lack of documentation (there are times when I thank God if I find a blog-post with an example for a library I'm trying to use). The notable exceptions are only those where the software itself is a complementary to something else that sells (like hardware, or ads) ... which is ironic since Microsoft was worshiped back in the day by many programmers for being a successfully pure software company (finally, our profession was going to have recognition).
So yeah, fighting a war against proprietary software is futile. Proprietary software will never be replaced by ideology. A better business model will (like <gasp> software as a service ... in which the software doesn't even run on your machine).
"a person who argues to defend or justify some policy or institution"
"Apologists are authors, writers, editors of scientific logs or academic journals, and leaders known for taking on the points in arguments, conflicts or positions that are either placed under popular scrutinies or viewed under persecutory examinations."
"One who makes an apology; One who speaks or writes in defense of a faith, a cause, or an institution."
It doesn't imply that there's anything to "apologise" for in the usual sense: it means "to defend" or "argue for".
Of the first 10, most are as you say, 2 are about actual apologies, and 1 is a "CIA apologist", which is in line with the above dictionary meaning.
It does tend to have the connotation you mention, but that isn't its only use in the mainstream press.