It also isn't only useful for computers. It helps people to know what they're getting into when they open a file.
An mp4 with a gifv extension makes sense to me. It says "I'll be loaded without audio and will play in a loop".
Imgur is serving text/html in their ".gifv" files. If you tried to load a gifv in a <video> tag it would crash and burn on you because...it's serving you an HTML document with a text/html MIME type.
Imgur will happily serve you GIFs and JPEGs with incorrect extensions - for example, if you get this image with a .gif extension, it's going to serve you a JPEG, and it's going to be decoded by libjpeg. The extension doesn't provide any useful information to the client about what to do with the data.
$ wget http://i.imgur.com/hDYj7E7.gif
--2014-10-09 14:00:53-- http://i.imgur.com/hDYj7E7.gif
Resolving i.imgur.com (i.imgur.com)... 23.235.47.193
Connecting to i.imgur.com (i.imgur.com)|23.235.47.193|:80... connected.
HTTP request sent, awaiting response... 200 OK
Length: 158352 (155K) [image/jpeg]
Saving to: ‘hDYj7E7.gif’
2014-10-09 14:00:53 (865 KB/s) - ‘hDYj7E7.gif’ saved [158352/158352]
$ identify hDYj7E7.gif
hDYj7E7.gif JPEG 577x1024 577x1024+0+0 8-bit DirectClass 158KB 0.000u 0:00.030…to browsers.
People like this format. GIF, gyfcat, Vine, and now this. Instagram and WebM on 4chan also have things keyed to this behavior. But the thing that GIF has on all of them is that it works everywhere. It plays in a browser, in an email, on the desktop, in an MMS message, etc..
We need a full stop replacement for the GIF that uses a modern encoder.
Keeping in mind that one of the big advantages of GIF is NO AUDIO.
It's just deeply anti-social to play audio in some contexts, and a file format which enforces that is a very good thing.
Perhaps GIFV or equivalent should be defined as either requiring the browser not to play audio or as making audio optional, but required to default to off at start of play. The latter would require a minimal transport control, but I could live with a transparent mouseover-only volume button. There's no technical reason that a GIF successor must include or play audio. For that matter it would make a greasemonkey script or perhaps extension that forced sound off for regular mp4 much easier to write in this case.