The Unsafety Net: How Social Media Turned Against Women
m.theatlantic.com
m.theatlantic.com
It's worth clicking through to the actual report [1]. For the several words they look at, they don't just count them. They break them down by gender of the tweeter, by comments (tweets about the word itself) and conversations (tweets where the word was used as part of the conversation), and how the word was used (non-offensive, colloquial, misogynistic, and so on).
For "slut" and "whore" in conversation, there is a really strong periodic component. The graph looks like a triangle waveform, with a big spike at the peak of the peak. It's probably a 24 hour period, but I can't really read it well because (for no reason that I can discern) they have used a spacing for the time grid lines of 1 day, 3 hours, 47 minutes?! See figure 5.
Figure 6 shows "slut" and "whore" in conversation tweets by gender. The graphs for males and females are nearly identical. They mention this in their "Key findings" section:
Women are as almost as likely as men to use the
terms ‘slut’ and ‘whore’ on Twitter. Not only are
women using these words, they are directing them at
each other, both casually and offensively; women are
increasingly more inclined to engage in discourses
using the same language that has been, and continues
to be, used as derogatory against them.
Is it misogynistic for a woman to call another women, with offensive intent, a slut or whore? Or is she simply being a jerk?[1] http://www.demos.co.uk/files/MISOGYNY_ON_TWITTER.pdf?1399567...
It's interesting, but this seems to be very true. Creating rules to behaviour seem to have the primary effect of spurring people to find ways to circumvent the rules. Any attempt at enforcing the spirit of the rules and not the letter leads to long diatribes on the nature of free speech coupled with some incredible persecution complex.
The interesting part is that the culture of a community is so incredibly fragile. They do not require a majority of bad actors, because beyond a very small number, these bad actors will quickly cause the original members of the community to leave and soon the ratio becomes more and more unbalanced spiraling until the community is no longer what it started out as.
Despite my aversion to overlords in real life, I find that online communities are most effective when strongly policed with unproductive dissent silenced outright. Not all dissent, just that which is unproductive.
My personal hypothesis is that while we see public places as public, and private places as private in real life, these distinctions are less clear online. Couple that with the problem where you don't know if a person is undesirable until after you've let him in and things quickly become hard to control.
I don't know if there is a solution.
It's the same in real life. We just like to pretend it isn't and keep policing out of sight. Many American (who can) up and move to gated communities, even join HOAs because neighbour's freedom to manage his own lawn is too much.
And who gets to pick what's productive or not?
That's always the hitch in these schemes: is criticizing decisions about what to police productive? is criticizing the beliefs of the owners productive? is not agreeing with the norm of the community productive?
The person making these calls has a vested interested in not seeing certain kinds of criticism and in accruing more power for themselves, so there's an inherent conflict of interest that tends to go wrong.
The community! That's what we're talking about here: how can the majority of some community avoid losing their own gathering place to a minority that makes the same place unhabitable for the rest. See Hacker News. Voting. Moderating.
Edit: Sometimes even resuliting in graying this very comment out. Which is OK if we beleive in the basic principle.
One could argue that we're already doing some form of community driven decision about what's productive on Hacker News (what, with the voting and what not), but you're clearly not happy with what people settled on through that method.
I am. And I'm also willing to risk having the post downvoted if it goes against what some "voters" would find offensive to their beliefs. For example, a lot of US people, including those on HN, believe it's not allowed to directly "talk negative" about any religion (when I just point to obvious aggresive teachings in them). And I beleive that that approach makes the world much worse.
But on private online platforms the owner/operator is in effect a dictatorship, and users can participate or not as they see fit. While free speech laws prevent official censorship, nobody is owed a platform for the expression of their views; so if some trolls are discomfited by being unwelcome at many social sites, so what? Why should their putative right to say obnoxious things take precedence over others' perfectly reasonable desires not to be harassed, and the site operators' (typical) choice to cater to the larger demographic?
It's not like it hasn't been tried before, it's just that policing ideas so rarely stops with just the trolls I'm skeptical of the whole premise.
It's an imperfect situation, but if you want to run a structured forum (eg the typical case of one that's dedicated to particular topics of mutual interest), then it's better than just establishing it and walking away, because without any sort of moderation at all the evidence is that it will quickly turn into a toxic shithole and be useless for its original purpose. Usenet's alt tree was the best example of a benign self-regulating anarchy but even that buckled in the wake of Eternal September and never really recovered IMHO.
You also need a lead figure who commands the community (possibly a rotating role) to settle disputes among your moderators.
Finally, a subtle hellban so some users think they're interacting with the entire community when they're just talking to and moderating each other.
I'd say there is: constant vigilance: HN still mostly manages to keep the quality by acive sppresion of the unwanted behaviour. There isn't "fire an forget" solution to such a problem.
I basically agree but I don't see Twitter or Facebook for example as communities. Those services are more like everybody at once all lumped together whether they like it or not. In the real world things like proximity and social interdependency force people to be more measured in behavior, interactions are mediated by cliques and groups with reputations and social pressure. In focused online communities you can make assumptions about content because it's opt-in and there is infinite space for alternative communities. I guess what I am getting at is that Twitter and Facebook are bad systems in that they don't give us bearings to make good social decisions on how to act (usually the opposite.) Facebook might actually be worse than Twitter in that it simulates communities but really a planet ruled by a weird dictatorship that doesn't care too much if you kill your neighbors as long as you don't embarrass the government. Twitter is like as if you have an instant 1-1 connection with every other living being which is why you get situations where a million people are each slamming the same person with one insult. It's horrifying but it's also very clearly not recognizable as a natural sort of social interaction so you shouldn't even expect it to be sane. It is a thing that literally should not exist. Something resembling Facebook could exist and be good, just not the Facebook we have now.
I used to think the anonymity of the internet was an outlet for a small minority of psychopaths, but aggressive online behavior towards women seems to become increasingly normal.
edit: s/them/themselves/
This woman's word choice is particularly revealing of the pervasiveness of misogyny in (our) human culture.
Keeping in mind that actual stalking has never been dealt with in any significant way ever, the desire of a few female writers to curb online anonymity wouldn't be enough to get an @ mention, except that this happens to coincide with what the media wants, and now we have the two vectors summing to form a public health crisis. "Cyberbullying is a huge problem!" Yes, but not because it is hurtful, HA! no one cares about your feelings-- but because criticism makes women want to be more private-- and the privacy of the women is bad. The women have to be online, they do most of the clicking and receive most of the clicks. Anonymous cyberbullying is a barrier to increasing consumption, it's gotta go.
...
If you're a guy, you probably don't realize the awesome pressure on women to let themselves get looked at: to reveal themselves online, to post a pic, to give everyone your attention, to stop what you're doing and give the other your self, even if they want to yell at you. "Hey lady, I hate you!" And yet that same pressure tells women they are valueless unless they are public. Madness.
The system is illogical, the things you want cannot actually coexist, but you dare not attack the system that promises everything, therefore something else must be blamed. As a basic example, Hess probably wants all the benefits of socialism and all the brand products of capitalism. When she can't have it, obviously the problem is misogyny.
Before even mentioning Sarkeesian the article reports on the threats and abuse suffered by 4 other women. Directly after mentioning Sarkeesian it details stories of 5 more women who have been harassed, violently attacked, or threatened.
So... Sarkeesian is the part that you latch onto here?
In other words: even an attention-seeking hack who misuses feminist talking points for personal gain should not have to suffer rape threats.
And it's very hard to take the very real problem serious if you got people like Sarkeesian (and Zoe Quinn, and Leigh Alexander, and so forth) poisoning the discussion. They are not harassed because of who they are. They are harassed because of what they say, and what they do.
Now I'm not saying that that's okay to threaten someone over their opinion, but there's a world of a difference between hating the political agenda a woman (or predominantly female group) is pushing and misogyny.
At some point, word like "misogynist" lose all meaning and become just insults that you either ignore or worse, take as a signal to discard the opinion of anyone who uses them wholesale.
I'd say that the people who issue these threats are poisoning the discussion a whole lot more than someone who argues in bad faith. And in the same vein, while it's annoying and hurts the cause of equality that some feminists will call anyone a misogynist who disagrees with their particular radical form of feminism, if you consider that a worse problem and spend more attention on it than on people who tweet "I’ll go to your flat and cut your fucking head off you inbred whore.", then you really are part of the problem and giving those feminists too much cause.
Because yes, I would argue that we shouldn't be paying attention to the trolls. They aren't poisoning the discussion because they aren't part of the discussion. They are trying to disrupt it from the outside, but any sort of moderated community they will be kicked out whenever they show up.
I would also argue that it might be worth differentiating between using misogynist behavior/rhetoric to attack a woman who you disagree with ideologically vs the sort of misogynist ideology that is the focus of the article. Misogyny as a means vs misogyny as an end, if you will.
And I really, really don't see any difference whatsoever between the two things you mention in your last paragraph. Definitely none.
If people are making legitimate threats, then it should be a serious matter. Otherwise,accept there are sad morons out there who don't get to say this stuff IRL, and don't let it get to you. Sorry ladies, but creeps will always exist. So some sad Redpill fucks are making comments about some chick tied up? Yes, it sickens me, but "do as thou will" until you actually harm another human.
Full disclosure: white middle class male.