Sounds like the tell-tale signs of socialist dysfunction, from which all the other problems stem. The solution is simple, but, unfortunately, poorly understood and highly resisted: restore a free market for health goods and services.
Sounds like the tell-tale signs of socialist dysfunction, from which all the other problems stem. The solution is simple, but, unfortunately, poorly understood and highly resisted: restore a free market for health goods and services.
One thing that would be good about a more free-market-y approach would be an increase in transparency about costs; but that's something that would be an improvement under a socalist or any other model as well.
Many medical services are repeated even if good service is provided. For example, 2 years ago I injured both my L5/S1 and L4/L5 disks. 2 years ago L5/S1 was treated, but the L4/L5 was left alone since it did not cause any problems. This year my L4/L5 started causing serious pain - the first guy did a great job so I went back. Another part of the feedback loop is reputation - if one of my friends needs similar treatment they'll probably go to the same guy unless they are very sensitive to cost (I didn't go for cheap).
I have no idea where this meme that free market health care looks like the US comes from. Maybe Canadians don't realize there are more possibilities than simply Canadian and US health care?
(I don't automatically disagree with your free-market assertion, mind you...we have quite a captive one here. You just need to use a bit better justification.)
.. opaque pools of collateral (subscriber) tranches, zero cost visibility, monopoly pricing power.. sounds like they're trading mortgage-backed securities. That didn't end well either.
E.g. You claim that the problem stems from HMO's spreading risk/cost using premiums, and doctors using that to over-charge fraudulently. But, have you considered why the doctors are able to do so (and get away with )? Perhaps because there is a shortage of them. Or something else, the point I'm trying to make is that we need to go a little bit further.
India shouldn't be in a Canadian's comparison set with respect to health care systems. The resource differences are too great to learn anything useful about the impact of other dimensions. Can you name a developed country with a health care system as or more free market than the American one?
As for your experience in India... Consider how much wealthier you are than the average Indian. If you were that much wealthier than the average American, do you really think you'd have any complaints about the American health care system? Conversely, what do you think your experience would have been if your wealth relative to the average American has instead been your wealth relative to the average Indian?
In contrast, there was a recent NYT article about a person in the US who underwent a similar surgery. A single billing discrepancy (to say nothing about the entire bill) is comparable to a software engineer's yearly salary.
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/21/us/drive-by-doctoring-surp...
Furthermore, the experience was easy, with none of the nonsense I deal with in the US. When I got to India, my initial medical exam cost roughly the same as a dinner at a decent restaurant. An MRI cost me the same as an expensive night out. I was given a price quote for the treatment and the total cost (including incidentals) was within 2-3% of the quote. The only person who even tried to rip me off during the process was the auto rickshaw driver who took me home.
Certainly the bill would have hurt me more if I were a typical Indian. But the experience I'm describing is not the wealth gap. I know people who are "that much wealthier" than the average American and they do have lots of complaints about the US system.