Beautiful Minds: Relations between genius, creativeness and mental illness
spacecollective.org
spacecollective.org
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=788259
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=795292
As I noted in each of those threads, the issue of connections between creativity and mood disorders has been studied at book length. The most authoritative of the several books on that issue is by psychologist (and mood disorder patient) Kay Redfield Jamison, author of Touched with Fire: Manic-Depressive Illness and the Artistic Temperament,
http://www.amazon.com/Touched-Fire-Manic-Depressive-Artistic...
and co-author of the definitive text on manic-depressive illness
http://www.amazon.com/Manic-Depressive-Illness-Disorders-Rec...
who has thought out loud in her writings over the years about whether treatments for depression that help suffering people may also deprive society of creative output. Her current thinking on the issue--and she takes lithium herself every day--is that the best-evidenced mood-stabilizing treatments for mood disorders are helpful to patients and increase rather than decrease their ability to contribute useful work product to society. Her co-author, Frederick K. Goodwin, M.D., is still deeply skeptical of some antidepressant medications (e.g., the selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors) because of their capacity for inducing mania in many bipolar patients.
P.S. The illness of game theorist John Nash, the subject of the wonderful book A Beautiful Mind, was almost surely manic-depressive illness rather than schizophrenia. At the time he was diagnosed, American physicians misdiagnosed about 50 percent of cases of manic-depressive illness as schizophrenia, because of the mistaken diagnostic criteria used in Freudian psychiatry. Patients started getting better sooner in America as their diagnosis and treatment improved based on ideas from Europe (Kraepelin's diagnostic categories), Australia (lithium treatment for mood disorders), and America itself (cognitive talk therapy as pioneered by Aaron Beck, a former Freudian who found out that Freudian views of depression were incorrect).
There seems to be a seasonal surge of interest in this subject on HN right now. Hm.
http://www.sengifted.org/articles_counseling/Webb_Existentia...
a) There is some indication in some studies that high IQ is correlated with (that is, is a "risk factor" for) depressive illness. It is not at all clear what the causal mechanism may be, as correlation is not necessarily a sign of causation.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Correlation_does_not_imply_caus...
There is still ongoing research in various world cultures to confirm and explicate this finding of some studies.
b) Some parents who talk about "existential depression" are just engaging in euphemism. Their children have regular, everyday depression, just like some kids who are not gifted. There is no carefully controlled study at all
http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html
suggesting much uniqueness in the expression of depressed mood in high-IQ persons as contrasted with average-IQ persons.
Everyone who feels depressed deserves and needs compassion. (A fairly robust study finding is that persons who experience depression tend to experience less compassion from persons near to them than do persons who do not experience depression.) And gifted learners most definitely need educational provisions different from typical school programs. High-IQ adults may or may not feel they have a supportive social circle, depending crucially on their paths to higher education and the careers they pursue. Gifted people in general have special needs, and depressed people in general have special needs, and there may be a special intersection of needs in gifted people who are depressed, but it is not clear yet what role, if any, giftedness has in mood disorders.
As a more modern example, the happy few who have made fortunes anticipating the current financial crisis have a claim on the title "financial genius". The insanity is believing that you cannot be too highly leveraged because house prices never fall. The genius lies in not getting sucked into the madness at the time; it looks unimpressive later, after the bubble has burst.
"Unimpressive later" but how did it look at the time? If you break through to sanity despite being surrounded by collective insanity, your contempories look at you askance before delivering their verdict: it is you that is mad.
This does horrible things to our ability to look at the realtion between genius and mental illness. Even if the route to genius lies in cultivating sanity, us mundane onlookers will still come away with the idea that geniuses are mad and be tempted to go in the opposite direction.
People love that Niels Bohr quote "We are all agreed that your theory is crazy. The question which divides us is whether it is crazy enough to have a chance of being correct. My own feeling is that it is not crazy enough." but quantum mechanics does not need to be invented twice. The usual nature genius is to see through the turbid intellectual drama of one's own time to grasp ideas that will one day seem plodding and obvious.
Do they... ponder?
Eastman was an energetic, engaging and vivacious young man who had been brought low by a series of illnesses -- including severe back problems such that he could hardly walk from room to room without pain. That prevented him from going out and photographing, which was his lifelong passion. His children were grown, and his company had succeeded past the point of needing him day to day.
His summary of the situation was a pretty good one.
At least it's a step above freak, I guess.
Intelligence and the emergent phenomena it creates (strategic planning, willful competition) will logically overshadow almost everything else in determining group survival for higher organisms.
I suppose one could make a different but related argument that because certain mood disorders seem to be linked to creativity and intelligence, and because those things confer group advantage (in developing competitive strategy), depression might indirectly provide group advantage.
1 - Body. Every unit has a distinct physically cohesive component, that can symbolically be represented as a Circle.
2 - Nucleus. Every body has a distinct Center. (Queen Bee in the Hive.)
3 - Metabolic Network. Every unit is organized through the means of a metabolic network. (Bees use chemical signals.)
So if there is a 'higher' human, we need to identify these characteristic features. Of course, the cyber utopians would (plausibly) propose that it is machine mediation that will (finally) give rise to the higher human unit.
[edit/add: And Mystics, rejecting the black box model of Mind, would argue that meditation and group formation (e.g. Sufis and the Dance) that activates the higher man.]
It is not at all clear that the phenotype space is constrained by simple mathematical patterns (such as "center" as you mentioned). This sounds like religious analogy, not scientific thinking.
Mathematics is entirely independent of physics and is not a mere descriptive language. The second statement sounds "religious"; perhaps you can demonstrate a case in point?
"It is not at all clear that the phenotype space is constrained by simple mathematical patterns."
There was no mention of "simple" in the comment to which you have replied. Simply a statement of the fact that no amount of evolutionary development can give rise to the impossible.