Hacker News Reader

there isn't any way for a clip to measure your heart rate. previously you needed a strap around your chest with wet contacts. now you need a light sensor pressed against your wrist. but no one has done it with a clip on your clothes device

View on HN

I had a nephew who got excited when he saw HR done on watches. We did some research into accuracy and were surprised to find that the light-based tech used in many devices does not give you accuracy when you are running or generally moving fast. No idea about the fitbit devices but I am vary.

I assumed (incorrectly) that you just needed skin contact measure an electrical pulse (like an EKG machine).

However, that appears not to be the case. Even the wrist based optical ones are often times inaccurate.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com