Remote identity verification over the internet is not solved perfectly, but FIDO's U2F is pretty good. Hardware tokens cost money which most people won't buy, which is one problem. To prevent getting locked out you have to buy (and the service has to support) multiple hardware tokens, but that protects against loss or breakage. To prevent targeted token theft attacks, the token needs some kind of biometric verification (iris scans would be good), but that gets very expensive in a device that needs to be reliable and yet kept on a keychain.
That or something similar is the only way to provide verification while preventing the creation of a centralized identity database [I think a cryptographically assured identity verification system that dramatically limits identity repudiation would turn into a privacy nightmare dwarfing current identity database efforts being made by many companies]. With something U2F-like, each company or service stores their own verification seed value that is used in the future to verify you. It could be on a mobile device, like standard TOTP auth, or on a separate specialized hardware token. It could use pre-shared seed values and hashing, or nonces and asymmetric crypto.