There are plenty of cases where someone who has a grudge ignores the law and pollutes the search results, and then persistantly ignores attempts to enforce the law. Libel and slander are not criminal offences; the police are never going to get involved and there's no chance of prison.
In that narrowly defined situation it's reasonable for search engines to respond to requests to delist. They need to protect the quality of their search results. When I search for Fred Bloggs I don't want to know what one vexatious person with a vendetta thinks.