Virgin Galactic Is Rattled, but Undeterred, by Deadly Space Plane Crash
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
"It also emerged that three senior Virgin Galactic executives - the vice-president in charge of propulsion, the vice-president in charge of safety, and the chief aerodynamics engineer - had all quit the company in recent months."
"The Sunday Telegraph disclosed that Sir Richard's company, as well as US authorities, were warned about safety issues on numerous occasions, as long ago as 2007 when three engineers died in an explosion during testing of a rocket engine on the ground."
"Tomasso Sgobba, executive director of IAASS and the former head of safety at the European Space Agency, said that Virgin Galactic had refused to share information with industry experts outside the company and declined to have its rocket design peer-reviewed. Representatives of Virgin Galactic had refused to come to IAASS meetings, he said."
There's heaps more.
http://www.smh.com.au/technology/sci-tech/richard-bransons-v...
Of course if there was success people wouldn't be looking into this (as much), but that's par for the course.
When bad practices are involved, you either (a) succeed so all is OK, or (b) face the consequences when you fail.
The third option, (c) have bad practices and be left alone after you fail is not really productive or helpful for the industry.
The fact that some important employees have recently quit is suspect, I agree. But we don't know why they have quit, do we? Maybe the were not happy with their salary or there were other personal reasons. This is worth investigating, though.
EDIT: I just read the article and there seem to be plenty of other warning signs.
But declaring it a small incident? I would not.
tl, dr: we shouldn't pass judgement based on this article.
In the history of manned space flight, lots of unmanned experience was made before crossing that threshold.
It's tempting as a space enthusiast to see criticism of Virgin Galactic and Scaled's operations as attacks against spaceflight or commercial space activities or the space tourism business in general. But people should not let their enthusiasm carry them to far into ignoring the very real problems at VG and Scaled.
They have unquestionably taken a lax attitude toward security, as demonstrated most abundantly by the previous fatal accident at Scaled/VG which took 3 lives during a test that should have not injured a single person if they had been following standard safety practices. Moreover, they've consistently turned a deaf ear on criticisms of their engine design and its safety, criticisms which now appear to have been quite well founded.
Yes sometimes rockets are tricky. Sometimes bad things happen to otherwise good designs. That's the nature of probability. But bad things happen to bad designs too, and we should be sensitive to those circumstances.
With the design that Virgin Galactic / Scaled have now I don't see that as a reasonable possibility, and I don't think it is a safe system (largely due to the rocket, the airframe might be a perfectly fine design).
Where Raul Simberg makes the point that the fallacy of sunk costs is likely in play:
I also suspect that this will be the nail in the coffin for the hybrid program. Many in the industry (including me) told Virgin after the fatal test-stand explosion in 2007 that they needed to redesign and go to a liquid engine, but they had designed the airframe for the hybrid, and a liquid would have had different mass characteristics, probably necessitating a spacecraft redesign, which they were loath to do. The company appears to have been stuck in a “sunk cost” trap for years, with the belief that, despite all the years of delays, just a little more money and a little more time would finally get them to a workable engine. Yesterday morning, the trap snapped shut.
This (along with good HR) has been the secret to Virgin's success in what are basicly commodity businesses (retail, music, telecom, airlines). The free advertising and friendly governments (also PR targets) are a big advantage against competitors. Very little innovation required. However it is of limited value in a business requiring overcoming multiple technical challenges.
The cheap spaceports and celebrity endorsements are still quite valuable. They just need a partner that could actually make it fly but apparently these are in short supply. Perhaps only SpaceX?
“And once we find out what went wrong, if we can overcome it, we will make absolutely certain that the dream lives on.”
In other words unless there is a flaw in the design that makes it financially unviable to continue they will solve the problem and push on.
http://www.parabolicarc.com/2014/10/30/apollo-ansari-hobblin...
I thought his comments about Kevin Mickey (President of Scaled Composites) not wanting to stick around for questions yesterday were way out of line.
Now I realize that the early Mercury program was sub-orbital too, but that was gaining knowledge and practice prior to developing Mach 25 (orbital) technology. Is that also the goal of Virgin Galactic, to use the current design as a stepping stone?
So what I see is that they have a less ambitious goal. Even if they are 100% successful it won't give us a fundamentally new capability. The project is seemingly mismanaged, and they have a terrible safety record. Further more events like this might alter the perception of 'space tourism', affecting the business prospects of other respectable organizations.