Why (individual) Blogging Is Dead - Objective Measurement
sethf.com
sethf.com
This article was worth it, though, because it had a link to an older criticism, by Seth, of twitter: "A highly ranked person is free to attack anyone lower down the ranks, as there's no way for the wronged party to effectively reply to the same readers."
I hadn't thought about it that way. It makes sense now why the media is enamored with it: it allows an asymmetry similar to that of television and radio.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2009/may/07/twitter-is-...
I thought the whole point of blogging when it appeared was that anybody could write and anybody would write. It wasn't restricted to those who could afford a printing press or a pulpit.
The "A-list bloggers" aren't really bloggers in that sense, they're new media barons who happen to blog. If they move to twitter, they become new media barons who happen to twitter.
Besides, nobody makes money of twitter directly. It's just a platform for sending people to your blog...where you make money.
In school, American kids learn that their opinions should masquerade as facts. Opinions are worthless, facts are irrefutable. So, you don't dislike something, you argue that it's objectively bad. (The reader can then infer that you dislike something, but is forced to agree with you, since "facts" are, by definition, true and irrefutable.) As a result, people are on the lookout for words that can convey their opinion, but sound objective without significant factual backing.
"dead" is one of these words. People use it when they should simply say, "I see no future for ..." or "I don't like ...". But instead they say "dead" so that you have no choice but to agree with them; this thing is dead, there is no possible way you can continue to use or like it. It's not a matter of opinion -- it's dead!
(Of course, "dead" means declining, or that the rate of increase in use is declining, or something like that. This makes it harder to argue against, as the meaning is so far away from what is actually being measured.)
"dead" is dead.
Furthermore, any form of disagreement is less attractive as the reader is inclined to believe they have to argue with a fact, which is not attractive to do if they they presume the writer has done more research.
Result: the reader is obliged to agree, and turn another's opinion into their own fact.
Solution:
- have writer frame their viewpoint with "I think."
- have reader ask "prove it."
- have reader be aware of mental state of writer
Please try to explain why twitter has killed blogging in under 140 characters.
I'm skeptical of the (provocative) title: individuals will blog to the extent they want to, as they always have, and those with something to say will find a way to say it. As for "professional" blogging, I think to a large extent it's a myth, as I described in <a href="http://blog.seliger.com/2009/06/17/youre-not-going-to-be-a-p... not going to a be professional blogger, no matter what the WSJ tells you</a>.
When people tell you a medium has died, it usually means that medium has matured, at least somewhat, but the idea of being able to speak to anyone, anywhere, anytime, anyhow (as long as the receiver cares to listen) is going to stay, probably in some form that resembles blogging.
"blog reader-program development has ceased"
Shoot: <a href="http://www.macworld.com/article/142407/2009/08/gruml.html... forgot to tell the developers of Gruml and Byline</a>. Alternatively, someone isn't paying much attention.
Regarding Twitter, I like the comment in <a href="http://www.techcrunch.com/2009/08/17/why-i-dont-use-twitter/... I don’t use Twitter</a>: “What can be said in 140 characters is either trivial or abridged; in the first case it would be better not to say it at all, and in the second case it would be better to give it the space it deserves.”