That's because yesterday, it wasn't really 5%, it was 5±4%.
In other words, 'more uncertain than 5%' wouldn't be 5±x% , it's be, say, 6%. If you have no information at all -- you're as uncertain as you could possibly be -- the probability would just be your prior for this event, and the more data you get pointing to the event either happening or not, the more the probability will move away from your prior towards either 0% or 100%.