I find Fred uncharacteristically confused on this. We have local monopolies because cable (and phone) were built according to a utility model. Net neutrality is the legal reification of the utility model.
I find Fred uncharacteristically confused on this. We have local monopolies because cable (and phone) were built according to a utility model. Net neutrality is the legal reification of the utility model.
If you find that your netflix or youtube is slow, just VPN into a server with a real internet connection and be amazed at how fast the video loads, even with the encryption overhead, all because the VPN bypasses the ISP's domain based throttling. (Unless you're a youtube or netflix employee who can spin up a VM for your own personal VPN or somesuch)
Is it fair to the people who provide universal service that they would have to compete with companies are aren't required to do so?
It's not just expensive, it's fucking hard. Speaking as a guy who occasionally does this for a living.
The revenue you can make on a single phone wire these days just doesn't pay off in five years. Not in ten. Maybe in twenty years, but this break-even delay is too much for any investor who is not at government level!
And this is why speedy stuff like FTTH is deployed in cities and not in rural areas: digging costs approximately the same in rural as in city areas... and if it costs me as provider 50 k€ to wire up 100m of city street with 500 customers, that's paying off in a year. Wiring up a rural area with (if you're lucky, and I'm already leaving out real rural areas!) 50 customers takes 10 years to break even...
And this difference is why it is imperative that last-mile infrastructure building is done by a government entity charging the same amount of money for providing a bitstream Internet uplink to the customer - at a price point where the city customers subsidize the rural customers and the utility provider breaks even.
The added value by telecom providers renting the wires from utility can be e.g. faster peering to Netflix, Facebook caching servers in the next major city, etc.
Why? I'm really missing that logic step. OK, so rural is too costly to connect. But that doesn't follow that a specific solution is imperative, especially since the vast majority of the population lives in cities.
Why can't the government entity only build in rural/unprofitable areas, by imposing a tax on city connections? More: why can't the government entity simply subsidize the bills of rural users, adjusted to the extra cost of wiring their areas?
Thinking even wider, must we wire? What's keeping wireless point-to-point connections from working here?
Rarely a problem only has one solution, why is this one an exception?
Because charging every customer the same price regardless where he lives is widely accepted - but just imagine you had a "city tax" appear on your telco bill. You'd be outraged by it...
> Thinking even wider, must we wire? What's keeping wireless point-to-point connections from working here?
That one is easy to answer: people these days are afraid of radiation and high-voltage lines (NIMBY phenomenon). Also, you would not gain much from point-to-point-connecting a rural village as you'd still have to dig fiber into the village center which you then distribute to the individual houses. But as you are already in the village center, you could also just put a FTTC DSLAM box there and be done (this is what Deutsche Telekom is doing right now in a load of rural areas!).
edit: (microwave) point-to-point communication also usually requires expensive communication gear as well as individual (!) licenses from regulators. In addition during heavy rain, fog or snowfall communication quality decreases drastically, and heavy wind may displace the dishes.
Sure. Which is why you wouldn't charge a "city tax", you'd just charge a tax on everyone, but the subsidy to rural users would simply cover it (and part of the ISP price).
Also, you would not gain much from point-to-point-connecting a rural village as you'd still have to dig fiber into the village center.
I was actually thinking about connecting to the village using microwave, not (just?) to individual homes.
The "connect individual homes" part is the expensive part.
Just digging fibers across plain land is easy - just plough them in, bury pipework during road construction (actually mandatory in Germany!) or use existing sewer pipes. Or, even better, use existing overhead poles for HV or MV electricity.
The real question is whether the last-mile providers such as comcast should be obliged to provide settlement free peering at unlimited data rates with all transit providers is the real question. "Strong" network neutrality would say that they do, and, if Strong network neutrality turns out to be the law of the land, the implication will be that all ISP will transition to volume based pricing for their customers in order to make up for the loss in income that they got from selling transit rights.
A somewhat weaker version of network neutrality, but still useful, would suggest that comcast can charge for transit peering onto its network, but must do so on a non-discriminatory rate as established by regulators. I.E. Perhaps Comcast can charge 1$ /mbit/second charged @95th percentile, if they are determined to be a common carrier / title II applicable. Then providers like Netflix (or anyone, for that matter) that fulfilled the minimum operational requires (NOC, peering points, etc...) could purchase transit directly from Comcast. Alternatively, if they don't fulfill those technical requirements, or just don't want to bother, they can purchase transit from providers like Cogent/Level 3, who would resell at a bit of a markup.
That's the future I envision being the happy medium for consumers, last mile providers, transit providers, and content providers.
The exact thing I pay an ISP to do is to provide unlimited (up to my bandwidth plan) transit to the peering points of the services I want to use. They have no ethical or moral right to turn around and charge Netflix, Google, Crunchyroll, Vimeo, or anybody else for the thing I'm already paying for.
On the internet backbone, anybody who is purchasing "Transit" - that is, the ability to send data anywhere on the internet, pays for it per megabit/second, billed at the 95th percentile. What this means, is transit provider monitors an interface, and samples the data used every five minutes. (I.E. If at time n the interface indicated that 135 gigabits had been transferred, and at time n+ 5 minutes the interface showed that 145 gigabits had been transferred, then the 5 minute average would be 10 gigabits / 300 seconds or 33 megabits/second. These samples are taken for an entire month - 8640 of them in a 30 day month. Then, the provider sorts them in order, and removes the top 5% or 432 of those samples. They then charge the customer at the speed of sample # 433. This is what's known as "billing at 95th percentile". Note, that if sample 434 through 8640 had 0 usage, it would not matter - they still pay at sample #434. Also, note that if sample 431 through 432 were all at 10 gigabits/second, and sample #433 was 0 gigabits/second - the customer pays at 0 gigabits/second. (The transit provider protects themselves from that monkey business by also charging a fixed rate for the "Port Cost", which is unrelated to actual usage)
Now - we get back to what joe average customer does - let's say they download an average of 500 gigabytes of movies/itunes/etc... If they had been downloading that smoothly, over the entire month, that would be 1.5 megabits/second. Their ISP, if they didn't have settlement free peering, would have to pay for 1.5 megabits/second of transit. When I was last purchasing transit a while ago, "High" quality transit (Internap) costs about $3-$4/megabit/second, lower cost (like cogent), costs around $1/megabit/second.
In the case of Comcast, they have settlement free pairing with a number of providers, including cogent - but, Netflix decided to purchase their transit to Comcast from Cogent (because they were cheap) - and maxed out all the circuits between cogent and Comcast. Cogent was willing to add more interface - but, and here is where things get interesting - Comcast did not increase their capacity to Cogent.
At no point did Comcast ever preferentially de-prioritize Netflix traffic, nor did they de-prioritize Cogent traffic - they just didn't increase their capacity.
What's ironic, is that as soon as Netflix just decided to purchase directly from Comcast (at a rate that is rumored to be LESS than what they were paying cogent) then those cogent interfaces to comcast likely dropped down to much less utilization.
So - net-net, is that if comcast became a title II common carrier, and were restricted to charging a reasonable rate of return on their invested capital on their circuits (limiting their profit, but, oh well, such is the nature of government regulation in this situation) - then they should charge their ISP customers a markup on that rate of return, based on usage. A typical case might be charging $20/month for the circuit, but $2/100 gigabytes. This aligns everyones incentives. Comcast is highly incented to provide you REALLY fast circuits so you can download a lot. Comcast is also highly incented to provide GREAT transit access to their customers, so content providers can send a lot of data.
The Mom/Dad home user comes out great - because they probably are only downloading a few hundred gigabytes of iTunes TV (that will go up as HD and streaming TV become more common) - so their initial cost drops down to around $25/month.
The Heavy users, that comcast was previously rate limitting because of violating the "Reasonable Use" clause, is now considered to be a premium customer - who might even get a (negotiated with the regulator) break based on their high volume.
In this new world - if you want to download 5 terabytes of data - go for it. It will just cost you a $100 + $20.
Everyone comes out ahead except for Comcast shareholders and executives, who won't be able to profit on their monopoly rents any more.
Anyways - if I was the regulator with a magical wand - that's the system I would be setting up.