No, because ISPs aren't common carriers. It's a pretty common political position (among those who care) that ISPs should be common carriers.
No, because ISPs aren't common carriers. It's a pretty common political position (among those who care) that ISPs should be common carriers.
Because Title II would put an end to all this shit.
The common carrier designation solves an entire slew of problems that were previously experienced with other technologies as well. It addresses privacy, liability for what you are delivering, etc.
>liability for what you are delivering
While I fear further regulation may introduce unforeseen consequences or inhibit innovation, I also fear doing nothing is proving to have problems as well. Regulations need to be written by people with the knowledge to be very precise about how things are done; we don't want mandatory ISP deep packet inspection (I already get letters from my cable company about HBO torrents that I download).
http://www.cisco.com/web/about/ac123/ac147/archived_issues/i...
Effectively, common carriers are protected from liability unless they know that what they carry is not legal.
<comment class="devils-advocate">
Given that logic, wouldn't it mean that an ISP is basically obligated to block traffic to, say, the pirate bay when they become aware of it?Effectively, the only sustainable way to maintain common carrier status is to maintain a deliberate ignorance of the legality — or lack thereof — of any traffic they might carry.