"working poor" is an oxymoron in comparable countries. Like it should be. I'd be laughing at it if it wasn't so bloody tragic. How is this not a top political issue?
Early voting seems to be possible in most states, and with at least 4 days of voting before the tuesday, most people should be able to do it. How can it not be a requirement for all states to provide early voting?
So no amount of resources or effort will ever convince that party to adopt a policy requiring ID's since that will result in the loss of at least some votes which would hurt them.
If you include voting rights for ex-convicts or even voting in prison you'd more than counter the effect of voter ID (this I assume would not be a popular opinion among R?)
Only about half the states require citizenship to vote, this can be trivially verified on wikipedia. Its technically illegal at the federal level to vote in a federal election if you're not a citizen but that's only enforced politically "making examples of" and voter intimidation purposes and so forth.
It seems among the young HN participants, or maybe foreign participants, there is culturally almost no understanding of whats federal and whats state level in the USA. I would assume this is an intentional goal of the educational system, to make control of the population simpler. There is also an undercurrent of those who actually understand this simple fact not saying much, because "everyone knows" that you get 50 states into a big pile, anything you say about them can and will be wrong in some minor detail in one state and your entire argument will be viciously attacked because being only 98% right is the same as 0% right.
There is also at least a three step game being played where the first step is "demand ID to vote" rather than the existing "we trust you" system. The second step is state ID is technically free if you have the documentation required. The third step is making the documentation required change annually and sometimes be very expensive, almost impossible to obtain and you can always blame the victim for not having all the right paperwork.
My wife doesn't have a "real id" because it would just cost too much and be too much of a PITA to fix, so when a "real id" level license is required to vote, she'll be disenfranchised from voting. Eventually it will be enough of a PITA for her to obtain the docs she needs and we can certainly afford it, its only $100 or so, but that's a weeks labor for other social classes... very much intentionally.
And no, as a European I very frequently do not understand what is governed on your federal or state level. In fact, this separation has never ever been mentioned in my own education,and I only know of it because I frequent places like HN.
Its that taxation without representation thing, still an issue two centuries later, if you pay taxes, even just road taxes via gasoline for your car, you get to vote on who spends the tax money ... More practically we use voting as a propaganda technique to calm the voters... "we don't have an oligarchy or dictatorship, you get to choose between two carefully chosen (by us, not you) candidates, and they do have different PR firms... see? thats real freedom so stop complaining!"
"Also, the problem with US citizens not being just given IDs is also bizarre"
We've historically had problems with J Random Criminal walking up to the counter and asking for someone else's ID and then doing very bad things with it. My own mother supposedly bought a truck in Texas last seen at the border crossing to Mexico, that's only 1000 miles away. Culturally we have a lot of people who work on commission and don't really care about much other than collecting that commission check. We could have .gov bankroll the substantial costs of identity paperwork, but 1) technically you're not supposed to throw away your birth certificate, so the guy who "lost" it should have some skin in the game, so bill them $100 and 2) Obvious voter suppression. At least poor voter suppression. Also aside from cost its a confuseopoly type of situation.. profiting off people being confused. Another thing we're really into culturally.
"demanding such paperwork is seen as discriminatory"
By a subset of the population with a political axe to grind, yes. Everyone else (maybe 80% of the population?) sees it more as common sense other than it has been used for oppression, stopping people on the street and only demanding papers from certain racial groups.
"this separation has never ever been mentioned in my own education"
Join the club, which unfortunately includes most Americans who've lived here their whole life and don't understand which laws are local, state, or federal. If you think our laws are confusing, try the building codes some time (ugh).
This also is comical because there is a cultural meme on HN that "we" all live in SV or Manhattan even though most of us actually do not. Like us two. So someone will comment about electrical codes for 3-phase wiring for the NAS in their basement in Mountain View as if the whole country works the same way, which it certainly doesn't. Or voting, which is regulated by state.
I will add one more thing to this discussion:
" if you pay taxes, even just road taxes via gasoline for your car, you get to vote on who spends the tax money"
Interesting you say this, because this is one thing that should work like this in EU, but it doesn't. As a EU citizen living in a country that is not the country of my birth, I am in a situation where I pay all the taxes like everybody else, I pay income tax, I contribute to national insurance, pay road tax with my petrol, once I get old I will receive a state pension from this country, the whole deal - I literally don't pay anything in my home country anymore, so from the "tax" point of view, I am no different than any other "citizen" of the country I currently live in. However, I cannot vote in parliamentary elections of this country, because my passport has the wrong country on it, even though for all other purposes it doesn't(and in fact, it by law cannot) make any difference as long as we are inside the EU.
The one time they do hire a guy to fix things, it turns out he can't do it because Congress obstinately blocked his way at every pass. His political rivals turned a compromise, non-universal health care plan into a three ring circus that somehow made the poor think things were getting worse for them, despite how many have been able to get access to healthcare for the first time in their lives.
Unfortunately for us, the guy we hired just doesn't have a strong enough backbone to stand up to the legislature and the FCC and the corporations and tell them in no uncertain words that this situation is no longer acceptable. Polite, articulate words simply won't cut it anymore.
I come from Kentucky, the state with one of the most successful deployments of the health care program in the nation, and Mitch has actively campaigned on repealing it, right to their faces, and yet they supported him at the polls. That's how fucked up this situation has become. It's quite hard not to be disenfranchised and think there's nothing we can do.
An issue only becomes political in the US if the two major parties disagree on it, which is to say if different sectors of American big business disagree on it. It's important to remember that there is no major political party in the US that does not represent big business interests, so concerns around income and wealth inequality, poor working conditions and so on do not rise to the level of "political issues" despite almost universal agreement by actual citizens that they are a problem.
There was a study posted on HN or reddit the other day showing that when people don't like the political implications of a solution to a problem, they minimize the existence of the problem.
There is an easy solution to the plight of the working poor in the U.S. Raise the minimum wage, and establish legal restrictions on the schedules companies can assign workers. To the extent that pushes people out of the work force (i.e. companies choose to not hire certain marginally-qualified workers rather than give them better shifts), expand welfare to cover those people.
This is a politically untenable solution here in the U.S. because even our economic liberals aren't liberal enough to be comfortable with telling Wal-Mart that there is no reason to have stores open 24-hours a day.
It's very strange if both political parties try to uphold the image that it is in peoples' best interest to be anti labour and anti-union, or even that pro-business implies anti-union.
You can't just claim that having a larger safety net or higher paying jobs will help as most of these individuals have a pattern of poor choices and personal vices that will eat away at any additional assistance they are given. That might not be true of everyone, but its true of the vast majority. There is no way to fix this fundamental break down of society at the governmental level without greatly impinging on the right of those effected.
It's important to realize that you're making all of this up in order to rationalize your position. You can't just claim that this is true without research or reference.
edit: You could find out how many of the working poor match your internal fantasy of them, and how many don't, if you really wanted to know. The answer would cause you a lot of painful cognitive dissonance, though, because you like to think of yourself as a good person while explaining why people who work full time jobs don't deserve to eat, and how even if they had the money, they would spend it all on booze anyway.
In essence, you're also making claims about the state of the poor, yet you also didn't provide any research or reference (which you accuse the OP of not doing either). I'm not saying you are, but it's equally likely (from our point of view, assuming it's unbiased) to think that you're also rationalizing your view of the poor to match your own position.
In essence, I'm not. I'm responding to a bad argument. You can't just go on a rant about unicorns on the South Pole, and when people tall you you don't know what you're talking about, ask them all to prove you wrong. That's not how reason works.
edit:
>Why not start the discussion by asking him what he means by "poor choices and personal vices"?
Because there's nothing in this ancient, stereotypical rant of the comfortable since antiquity that gives me the indication that I have something to learn about the poor from the person who happens to be reciting it in this thread. I've been poor, and I know poor. If there are some statistics that tell me that I've just accidentally been in a bubble of the wonderful, hardworking, generous, and thoughtful poor (mixed with a few spoilers) I'm open to it and happy to read it.
And if I had no prior-opinion OR evidence on unicorns in the South Pole, I'd equally be skeptical of your claims that there aren't any, as I'd be of the guy that claims there are. I'd ask you both for some basic stats/research on the matter, which is what I tried to point out.
Agreed, especially if you have a more controversial viewpoint. I know that all too well.
However if you want numbers just go look at the census data. Here is an analysis by kidscount (http://datacenter.kidscount.org/data/tables/107-children-in-...) and I can tell you from my experience that number is low. There are many other families where they are not "single" parents, but the second adult is just a boyfriend who may or may not be the father of the children in question.
Not having parents to pay for college isn't a "poor choice".
Since finances are the leading cause of divorce, it would be reasonable to expect that lower income families have more single-parent homes.
It's frankly immoral to consider marriage (and divorce) a luxury the poor are somehow less deserving of.
If I were to get a divorce, it wouldn't ruin me.
I have seen a number of middle class kids make "poor choices" that would have devastated a poor family. The children of poor families don't "fail upwards" in the way that upper middle class kids do.
I worked very hard to achieve what I have. But I recognize that without the help of family who could afford to help, the work alone would not have been enough. I've found a healthy dose of success in spite of some poor choices.
Your POV is typical of people who've had the luxury of not having to depend on a two hour bus commute to get to a job that offers no vacation hours. Where every trivial emergency is one that hits you twice: Once to pay for the event itself, and once for the lost work hours. It's a position of privilege.
1. a very low percentage of minorities even get married. Meaning divorce is a statistical outlier [http://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21569433-america...]
2. Low income teens are likely to get pregnant while in high school. This has nothing to do with mommy and daddy not being able to pay for college and them getting stuck in a dead end job while trying to raise a family. These kids are dropping out of school and having kids before any prospect of a job is on the table. Then they have to deal with the fact that they have kids and it limits their choices ( can I go to school and work two jobs while raising kids ? )[http://www.nber.org/papers/w17965.pdf]
Yeah right some kids can get away with more poor choices but that doesn't mean they are not poor choices, and while I don't think there is a good body of evidence for this exact situation, even kids who are middle or upper middle class who have kids early in life and have their parents who can cover for them, their kids are statistically likely to make the same poor choices and the parents are not as likely to be able to support them. So the first generation might be able to "fail upwards" but the second generation which is statistically likely to fail as well will be much less likely to do the same thing.
25% is not insignificant. And of course the lower on the socioeconomic totem pole you go, the more divorce you find.
And when you don't have prospects, then maybe you're a little more careless about behavior that would interfere with those nonexistent prospects. I feel like it's no great secret that many young people these days delay starting a family for college and career.
It seems reasonable to expect that the opposite might be true as well for people who don't have the same opportunities.
As for your last point, that doesn't nullify anything you know? If you start out on 3rd base, you will face fewer consequences. No surprise. You might not slide into home, but the people who started out at-bat are still unlikely to catch up with you. See wealth-gap, class mobility, etc.
However I while I can't find the numbers for that specific town I imagine they don't deviate from the national statistics of 70+% of minority children in single parent households. The social structure _has_ broken down and we keep ignoring it like its not a problem.
Also, whether a household is one-parent or two-parent is irrelevant to the childcare situation. Two parents with late night shifts aren't going to have an appreciably easier time than one parent. And your point about grandparents is also inapposite. If you have small children, it's unlikely your grandparents are old enough to already be out of the workforce.
So your numbers make sence. First generation Immigrants typically move as family units. They would also lack the social net to assist with kids, so they might be prime candidates for this kind of service.