Marx and Engels took Hegel more seriously than he deserved. Lenin took Marx and Engels more seriously than they deserved. Hitler took Neitzche more seriously than he deserved.
Marx and Engels took Hegel more seriously than he deserved. Lenin took Marx and Engels more seriously than they deserved. Hitler took Neitzche more seriously than he deserved.
Insofar as that's arguably true of the 19th and 20th Centuries, its equally true of most of the centuries before those as well, and also so far of the one we've seen after that.
> Lenin took Marx and Engels more seriously than they deserved.
How seriously could Lenin have taken Marx and Engels to take the rhetoric of Marxism while throwing out its entire theoretical underpinning?
They saw themselves or strived to be "the Newton of __". Marx' theories of history an politics were treated as a theory in the same sense as darwin's was. They named the departments political science. We are still dismantling many of these ideas, especially in areas like economics or psychology where they use math or experimentation and seem more scientific.
Aside from a general political war on science from a certain faction in general (and not specifically on social science), I don't see dismantling of any of the ideas of science being applied in these domains. On the contrary, I see increased sharing of tools, mechanisms, and ideas between mathematics (including, e.g., computer sciences), the social sciences, the life sciences, the physical sciences.
There might be a rejection that Marx's work is good (or even methodologically valid) science -- but there was plenty of that from Marx's contemporaries, too. But there certainly is not a general rejection that the subject matter that Marx studied is amenable to scientific investigation.
Marx is a good example, he strived to (and claimed to have) put forward theories on politics, history, ethics & economics that were the somewhat like of Darwin's theory on the origin of species. That they could be validated and built on in the same way. Further theories and technologies could be based on them in the way that rockets can be built based on Newton's mechanics.
The left isn't unique here. Ayn Rand is almost a caricature of this point, partly because she actually deals with modernism as a subject matter. She claimed to have described a theory of morality derived from pure logic and politics derived from morality.
There are some fields where "scientific" endeavors produce some outcomes, but have never really driven the kind of progress that was hoped for or claimed. Psychology and economics are big ones, IMO. Early economists like Ricardo could pose theories that work logically and are somewhat available for experimentation or prediction-measurment, but the kind of theories produced by modern economists like Marx, Keynes or Friedman (to be balanced) are not testable. They also haven't really produced any decent technology based on them or a reliable understanding of the mechanics.
Whether or not "the humanities" or the areas between humanities and sciences are amenable to scientific investigation is a big question. I'm not confident in any clear answer but I suspect the truth is that there's a spectrum. I am pretty confident though that the subject matters have been, up until now, for less amenable to scientific investigation than biology, physics, chemistry, etc.
If I had to bet on a solution to addiction, I would place a bet on either a neuroscience approach or a totally nonscientific approaches (like AA or religion) over psychoanalysis. I have almost no confidence in the idea that a theorist will figure out a better form of government. The process that will drive these things will probably continue to be cultural emergence.
I'm not saying that humanities are useless. I'm a big fan of the humanities. I'm not saying that science is bad either, I'm a fan of these too. I am saying that modeling the sociology or genera sturdies departments on the physics one turns out to have been a mistake. It hasn't been productive and it doesn't produce science or its derivatives.
I think many of Marx' ideas are valid, particularly his definition of class. I think his (and most modernist "political scientists") insistence that his theories on history or political progression are based on logic and science or that they can be is like a monarchy's insistence that they are chosen by the gods. Bunk.
Curious, I've never heard of this link/reason before. Care to elaborate a little, or some links, please?
https://www.google.com/search?q=hitler%20nietzsche%20philoso...
Nietzsche was anti-democratic and anti-socialist, yes. In most of his works he goes to extreme lengths (almost pathetic lengths) to rant against German nationalism and German antisemitism. Nietzsche was, without a shadow of a doubt, one hundred percent opposed to the Nazis.
Indeed this was the primary reason for his split with (and apparent hatred of) his sister. The Nazis may have co-opted Nietzsche but they hardly be said to have taken him seriously.
From a draft letter to his sister:
After I read the name Zarathustra in the anti-Semitic Correspondence my forbearance came to an end. I am now in a position of emergency defense against your spouse's Party. These accursed anti-Semite deformities shall not sully my ideal!!"
From Gay Science: [...]we are not nearly "German" enough, in the sense in which the word "German" is constantly being used nowadays, to advocate nationalism and race hatred and to be able to take pleasure in the national scabies of the heart and blood poisoning that now leads the nations of Europe to delimit and barricade themselves against each other as if it were a matter of quarantine. For that we are too open-minded, too malicious, too spoiled, also too well-informed, too "traveled": we far prefer to live on mountains, apart, "untimely," in past or future centuries, merely in order to keep ourselves from experiencing the silent rage to which we know we should be condemned as eyewitnesses of politics that are desolating the German spirit[...] We who are homeless are too manifold and mixed racially and in our descent, being "modern men," and consequently do not feel tempted to participate in the mendacious racial self-admiration and racial indecency that parades in Germany today
Indeed Nietzsche went so far as to deny he was German at all but rather of Polish descent even though this was almost certainly not true and he almost certainly would have known it, simply because of his opposition to the German nationalism and anti-semitism that had overtaken Germany - basically in a big F U.
Hitler reinterpreted Nietzsche's will to power, yes.
> It also seems to me that Hitler took the "superman" idea - the man who is above morality and can do whatever he wishes to those below him - but I'm less certain of that.
The ubermensch is not a moral nihilist who can do whatever he wants, he's the answer to the moral nihilism that is the inevitable consequence of the death of god. This is very hard to reconcile with Nazi ideology which promoted (their version) of Christian Protestantism and genocide for racial reasons, which Nietzsche maligned.
> The ubermensch is not a moral nihilist who can do whatever he wants, he's the answer to the moral nihilism that is the inevitable consequence of the death of god.
Yes and no. The ubermensch comes into a situation where there is no god, and therefore there is nihilism - there is no moral authority. The ubermensch creates a moral authority. But because there is no god and therefore no external moral authority, there really is nothing constraining the ubermensch to create any particular moral standard. The moral standard created is therefore essentially arbitrary. That is, by his choice of morality, he can proclaim that it is moral to do anything to others.
(Now, true, Neitzche said that the morality was supposed to be life-affirming, as opposed to other-world centered moralities that were not. But in a nihilistic context, there are few constraints on what "life affirming" might mean, and in practice it will come to mean anything the ubermensch might wish. Anyone wishing to say otherwise must not be coming from a nihilistic position, which means they must be either pre-death-of-god, or be ubermensch themselves.)
Yeah, if you think Stalinism is what Marx and Engels had in mind...