Quantum teleportation demystified
blog.rongarret.info
blog.rongarret.info
The second thing to do is to stop reading any article that ever says anything remotely resembling, "the photon/atom/whatever was teleported..." since that is a flat-out falsehood that only a ignoramus or a liar would publish.
No photon, no atom, no thing has ever been "teleported" nor ever will be. Only the quantum state gets "teleported", and the quantum state most decidedly does not have the ontology of a "thing". That is why the quantum world is so weird.
Quantum "teleportation" ought to be called something like "entanglement transfer", which has the advantages of being a) fairly accurate and b) hard to use in the misleading and dishonest ways "teleportation" gets used.
> No photon, no atom, no thing has ever been "teleported" nor ever will be. Only the quantum state gets "teleported", and the quantum state most decidedly does not have the ontology of a "thing".
I used to think the same thing as you, but if you accept quantum mechanics as complete and accurate, then the quantum state describes the totality of the system. There is nothing more than the state -- no other hidden variables.
So it comes down to the philosophical question: if you can make a perfect copy of something, except you have to delete the original version in the process (see the no-cloning theorem), is the new version the original "thing"? I would argue yes, it is. It's completely indistinguishable in every way.
(Now do I actually believe quantum mechanics is complete? I'm not sure I do. But if I assume that it is, then quantum teleportation is really teleportation.)
http://arxiv.org/pdf/quant-ph/0304158.pdf
In teleportation experiments to date only some degrees of freedom are teleported. So it doesn't usually make a whole lot of sense to say "the atom" was teleported. Rather, it'll just be the quantum state associated to nuclear spin states, or electronic degrees of freedom, or whatever.
I disagree with this particular bit. The state of Bob's photon changes exactly when Alice does her measurement [1]. Why? The state of a photon is given by 2 real numbers (infinite bits). Bob receives 2 bits of information from Alice so his 1/4 operation can't change the state of the photon to an arbitrary state.
The 'magic' does happen when Alice measures her state. After her measurement Bob's photon is in one of four possible states, which are the same up to 2 swaps. The 2 bits of information are needed to find out which swaps to perform. This swapping step nicely prevents faster-than-light travel.
[1] Caveat. In a relativistic universe, ordering of events depends on the frame of reference. All arguments carry through when this is taken into account.
Edit: I should explain how this saves relativity. No measurement (weak or strong) can distinguish which pre-swap-state Bob has. You can try to be clever and ask Alice to teleport millions of photon states to Bob. But that doesn't help either because each of the four states are equally likely in the whole ensemble. So you need 2 bits of information per teleported photon state to get the correct final state each time.
No, it doesn't. If it did, then this would lead to faster-than-light communication. The whole concept of "exactly when Alice does her measurement" isn't even well defined!
> Why? The state of a photon is given by 2 real numbers
Actually they are complex numbers. But this part of your point is valid nonetheless.
> The 'magic' does happen when Alice measures her state.
No, the "magic" happens when the entangled pair is first produced. Alice's measurement changes nothing on Bob's side.
The majority of experts I know feel like it's futile to try and correct the media's representation of their field. I think QM has it doubly hard as it has all the issues of other technical field, while suffering from both the problem of its ontology being foreign to the lay-person and certain key points of its ontology are still debated within the field.
I'm sure a lot of scientists don't mind media-hyped and somewhat inaccurate coverage of science news because it's actually interesting to the layperson. The reality is that the general population is pretty blasé about even fluff science reporting - let alone accurate reporting.
So a little hype, even if inaccurate, probably goes a long way towards getting people interested in science. And that's a good thing for a) producing future scientists and b) securing funding.
I agree that they ought to be held to a higher standard, but I think that the motivation of scientists for not doing so is more out of apathy, and less out of a desire to seem more mysterious.