The Pirate Bay is entirely different from stealing intellectual property, and I'm disappointed to see these two things being lumped together here.
Also, I'd be careful throwing the word "censorship" around. What Roskomnadzor is doing here isn't terribly different from DMCA takedown notices or governments "censoring" documented child abuse.
As someone who has their intellectual property shared by The Pirate Bay I disagree.
Compare The Pirate Bay to YouTube. An argument can be made that YouTube is the biggest distributor of pirated content, though you'd never make YouTube responsible for that. YouTube is a platform and so is TPB. Nobody would ever suggest blocking YouTube as a whole just because people use the platform to share copyrighted material — yet quite a lot of people think doing the very same thing to TPB is completely reasonable. I don't get that.
I agree that the tool itself shouldn't be banned, but the idea of pushing for compromise (e.g. giving recognised authorities access to view users' details in cases where illegal material's being shared) doesn't seem unfair. This way the authorities have options other than banning the tools, legitimate users don't suffer, and offending users are identified; all's good - unless you're using the tool illegally; which is fine (or at least, a different debate).
Some studios have suggested that, and were campaigning for restrictions for Youtube. Hence YouTube's content filtering which recognizes and removes certain content automatically.
Roskomnadzor had a story with YouTube, had them blocked for several hours (mostly went unnoticed as IIRC they had banned only a single IPv4 address, and most ISPs hadn't even pulled the registry before the block was lifted), and had made them block a copy "Dumb Ways to Die" video in Russia.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dumb_Ways_to_Die#Censorship_in...
So, the fact is, somebody had not only suggested but actually proceeded with blocking YouTube as a whole.
That's wrong of course, hence it's completely different to stealing. Just becaue copyright infringement and stealing both have potential financial impact doesn't make them coterminous.
This is the very definition of censorship. The DMCA also fits the description.
The fact that you feel censorship is always bad but can also think of a few examples where you agree with censorship and are experiencing cognitive dissonance is your problem.
It certainly doesn't help anyone to engage in doublespeak where you define different words for censorship you agree with and censorship you don't agree with. Well, it helps in political discourse immensely but it doesn't help anyone here.
The legal reasons behind the censorship are not important here, it all basically comes down to whether Github recognizes the local law of countries it serves content to, or not.
If I post suicide methods in English, would that be censored? If I post inflammatory information about Chinese or Indian politicians, would that censored?
When you start censoring, where do you draw the line? When you start allowing countries to extend their jurisdiction into 'cyberspace' how could you ever expect to not fall afoul of SOME law in SOME country. Do you only extend those concessions to large countries?
Ultimately it's github's decision to make in this case, but companies should have more than profit (or marketshare) in mind.
I find censorship repugnant. While I understand you have to comply with the laws of a country in which you are physically located, I think that should be the extent to which you accommodate things like this.
Their system is IP-based so censorship is customized depending on where you access Github from.
But I understand that to tackle the piracy problem is more practical to shut down torrent sites than to go after every single pirate.
The conclusion doesn't follow in any way from the premises.
Even if it doesn't "steal intellectual property" itself, why it's "wrong" to forbit access to it if "it's mostly used for that purpose"?
On the oft chance that some people also download legit stuff off of it? They can do that off of any number of sites that don't also feature tons of warez and pirated movies with direct download links.
A stance like "it's wrong because I believe intellectual property is wrong" is more consistent.
The Pirate Bay should be banned because people can use it to steal/share intellectual property.
Automobiles should be banned because people can use it to run over people.
Tor should be banned bacause people can use it share child pornography with it.
Scissors should be banned because people running with them can get seriously hurt.
People use TPB mainly to steal/share IP. People use cars mainly to get places efficiently, and occasionally by accident run people over.
Nobody sets out to get hurt while running with scissors (well, maybe some episode of Jackass). Nobody except the very rare psychopath sets out to run people over in their car. Almost everybody who goes to TPB is looking to steal/share IP.
And besides, we're not talking about weapons. We're talking about a website used to pirate content. I'm as logical as the next person here but people keep conflating these totally different issues on "logical" arguments.
A complete, world-wide ban on weapons wouldn't work because then you're leaving a window for some actor to make new weapons and exert that power. Shutting down torrent sites does not decrease societal stability, open anyone up to threats on their life, etc. Stop pretending guns and torrents are similar issues.
If cars were "mostly used for that purpose (running over people), then hell yeah, we should ban then.
And if "scissors" were mostly used by people running with them, then I guess we should ban them too.
I am a moral absolutist. I believe only action can have moral value (good or evil). This moral value is intrinsic and independent of context, intent or consequences. Killing for vengeance, killing in self defence and killing to save thousands of lives are all evil. Because killing is evil.
I also consider censoring, taking away and destroying something as bad. Everything in this world is unique, and was created either by natural means or by human hand. Even the most offensive and harmful thing should be considered as a product of this universe, and protected as such.
This way, I cannot approve of any decision that, in order to prevent/eliminate evil actions, either a) performs evil actions or b) censors, takes away or destroys something.
I say that TPB should not be banned or taken down. What should be addressed are the people who are using it to steal IP. What should be addressed are the people running over other people. What should be addressed are the people sharing child porn in Tor.
In the end, in my personal philosophy, the ends don't justify the means. Ever.
I know that in practical term, this is extremely naive. The world is painted in shades of gray. Sometimes we need to be practical when solving our problems. I'm just that hopefull bufoon that always tries to save the _Kobayashi Maru_ [1]
Why do you believe this?
I'm disappointed to see such manipulative propaganda language used here.
[/sarcasm]
Also the pirate bay just provides a hash ... hashing a file was still legal I think.