Maybe we just need to wait for HDR displays before we expect to see the full details of HDR imagery in a realistic way.
Maybe we just need to wait for HDR displays before we expect to see the full details of HDR imagery in a realistic way.
(start at page 53) http://www.slideshare.net/naughty_dog/lighting-shading-by-jo...
http://mynameismjp.wordpress.com/2010/04/30/a-closer-look-at...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ansel_Adams
The Disney Research team purposefully exaggerated their tonemapping far beyond what was aesthetically pleasing in order to clearly demonstrate the artifacts of other tonemapping techniques that their novel approach avoided. In an actual film, the editors would use much more subtle parameters.
But sometimes you also want to see what's going on. You don't have to turn the filter up to eleven. The fact that this filter performs so well even at exaggerated settings bodes well for its usability at tasteful, restrained settings. And it will probably make it a lot easier on cinematographers, so that they have to worry less about carefully lighting the set and can rely on being able to balance things out in post production.
It would have been nice to see some scenes with dialed down settings more "natural" results.
Obviously it isn't all like that. But when it's done well you shouldn't notice. Probably every time you notice tone mapping it is a bad example so you think all tone mapping is bad.
The examples near the end of the woman driving, and exiting the tunnel were pretty amazing examples.
Having said that, tone mapping is an essential photographic technique that has been used in one form or another since the beginnings of photography. It's purpose it to compensate for the poor dynamic range of the equipment or the picture's output media (paper, screen) and allow details in all brightness levels to be represented.
As with most photographic techniques, tone mapping is best used when the effect doesn't overwhelms the final product.
The goal of this video wasn't to make it look good, it was to produce a technology that can HDR frames in a temporally coherent way.
Further work is needed, but I strongly suspect that this will become a standard part of video editing.