Macros as a compiler implementation technique for standardized features are great; it's non-standardized macros I object to. That said I do think that in this case things would be improved by a single language-level feature, the equivalent of do notation or for/yield (and sure, probably implemented via a (single) macro). Then WITH-OPEN-FILE/WITH-OPEN-STREAM could become ordinary library functions and the common part would be evident, rather than macros that happen to have similar implementations but not in a way that that similarity is exposed to the programmer. And a programmer wanting to add support for a similar WITH-MYCUSTOMTYPE construct would only need to write a function, not a macro, just like they do in Scala.