That doesn't discount the fact that the surge pricing algorithm is still automatic. They don't have people sitting at their evil corporate HQ clicking buttons trying to maximize screwing people over.
No, but they knew what they were doing and can't claim they didn't choose to continue.
Although it's possible (no idea whether it's the case) they didn't have a mechanism to shut it down, on the time frame they would have needed to.
We can't philosophically disprove it. But Occam's razor applied to the behavioural evidence suggests Uber thinks surge pricing is fantastic, and keeping it in place during crises is corporate policy unless and until there's a media backlash large enough for it to actually get through their thick skulls that people are pissed off.
Presuming Uber thinks surge pricing is fantastic, wouldn't it be all the more likely they wouldn't build in a mechanism to disable it at the drop of a hat?
Possibly. But it's a red herring considering the issue is moral culpability and whether their behaviour is socially acceptable.
Their behavior, at this point, was "pay drivers out of their own pocket to help get people away from the emergency". It's hard to call that "socially unacceptable". It arguably took longer than it should have, but it takes time to make decisions in any large company. Hopefully they will learn from the experience, get better plans in place, and clarify policies for the future.
I wouldn't be surprised if surge over a certain % requires human intervention.
No, but that very algorithm was designed and implemented by humans from their big evil corporate HQ.