"In theory, picking a marketing person is easy, since the person who's best at marketing is the one who convinces you."
I dunno, I couldn't sell my way out of a paper bag and I still hosted that conference, which is well on it's way to being a valuable asset. Most of the people who showed up thought it would suck, but then they came anyway and liked it and now they'd come again. This was my strategy though and it worked, but clearly I'd never get hired for anything given your theory, which makes me suspect it may be more complicated than that.