The NSA accepts the reality you've presented. Is that what we want?
The topics of politically neutering well-funded governmental adversaries (that use gained data to drive "justice") and directly persecuting hacking are orthogonal. We currently have the worst of both worlds - unaccountable governments along with unlimited liability for running nmap or incrementing the number in a url.
In general, anonymity is directly opposed to accountability. Proper information security does not rely on after-the-fact accountability, so why should we think it prudent to give up anonymity?